Get the Athlon Sports Newsletter
Who will replace Butch Jones at Cincinnati?
Butch Jones was one of the top names in the coaching rumor mill over the last few weeks and decided to leave Cincinnati for Tennessee. Jones led the Bearcats to a 23-14 mark in three years, which included a share of the Big East title the last two seasons. Jones’ departure is a huge blow to Cincinnati, as the program will be looking for its fourth head coach since 2004.
10 Coaches to Replace Butch Jones at Cincinnati
Dave Clawson, head coach, Bowling Green –Clawson took a lot of heat for Tennessee’s struggles on offense in 2008, but he is a proven head coach at three different stops. The New York native went 29-29 in five seasons at Fordham (1999-2003), which also included a trip to the FCS playoffs in 2002. Clawson jumped to Richmond in 2004 and led the Spiders to two playoff appearances, including an 11-3 mark in 2007. After the failed season at Tennessee, Clawson landed at Bowling Green and went 7-6 in his debut year and 8-4 in 2012.
Kerry Coombs, Ohio State assistant coach – Coombs is regarded as an excellent recruiter but has no head coaching experience on the collegiate level. He spent 2007-2011 as an assistant at Cincinnati, before joining Urban Meyer at Ohio State in 2012. Coombs was a high school head coach at Colerain High School from 1991-2006, so there’s no doubt he has excellent recruiting ties throughout the state. Hiring a head coach without any experience is risky, but Coombs would be able to pull in solid talent and likely wouldn’t look to bolt for another head coaching job.
Bob Diaco, defensive coordinator, Notre Dame – Diaco's name was mentioned in the Boston College search, so there's no question he is interested in becoming a head coach. And Diaco is familiar with the Cincinnati program, serving as an assistant under Brian Kelly in 2009. He also has spent time as an assistant at Eastern Michigan, Western Illinois, Central Michigan, Virginia and for the last three years at Notre Dame. Diaco has no head coaching experience but has helped to lead the Fighting Irish to a rank of No. 1 overall in points allowed (10.3 ppg).
Tom Herman, offensive coordinator, Ohio State –Herman is a longshot in this coaching search but a rising star to watch over the next couple of seasons. The Ohio native started his coaching career at Texas Lutheran in 1998, before working his way through the ranks at Texas, Sam Houston State and then as an offensive coordinator at Texas State from 2005-06. After two years with the Bobcats, Herman worked at Rice as the offensive coordinator, then jumped to Iowa State in 2009 and came to Columbus to work with Urban Meyer.
Pete Lembo, head coach, Ball State – Lembo is a proven winner at three different stops during his coaching career and is ready to move up the ladder after two years at Ball State. He recorded a 44-14 mark in five years at Lehigh and a 35-22 record in five seasons with Elon, which included an appearance in the FCS playoffs. Lembo is 15-9 in two years with the Cardinals and improved his win total by three games from 2011 to 2012. Although Lembo might be looking to jump to a better job in the next few years, he would continue Cincinnati's run of recent success.
Mike MacIntyre, head coach, San Jose State –MacIntyre has turned San Jose State into one of the WAC’s worst teams into a bowl team in just three years. The Spartans went 1-12 in 2010, improved to 5-7 in 2011 and recorded a 10-2 mark and an appearance in the Military Bowl in 2012. MacIntyre has stops as an assistant at Temple, Ole Miss, Duke and in the NFL with the Cowboys and Jets. MacIntyre isn’t a flashy or a big name, but as the results have shown at San Jose State, he’s capable of leading a BCS program. If Cincinnati is interested, it could have plenty of competition for his services, as MacIntyre could get in the mix at South Florida or Colorado.
Chuck Martin, offensive coordinator, Notre Dame –Although Brian Kelly plays a large role in calling the plays each week for Notre Dame, Martin should get his chance to be a head coach on the FBS level in the next few seasons. He succeeded Kelly at Grand Valley State and recorded a 74-7 mark in six seasons, including back-to-back national titles in 2005-06. Martin came to South Bend in 2010 and spent two years on defense, before moving to offensive coordinator in 2012. With his background on offense and successful stint at Grand Valley State, Martin fits the mold of what Cincinnati is looking for in its next head coach.
Pat Narduzzi, defensive coordinator, Michigan State – Narduzzi isn’t an offense-first coach like Cincinnati has hired with Brian Kelly and Butch Jones, as he has spent his entire career on defense. However, Narduzzi has helped to mold Michigan State’s defense into one of the nation’s best and has been rumored to be in the mix for a couple of head coaching jobs over the last few seasons. Narduzzi spent from 2004-06 at Cincinnati, working as the defensive coordinator under Mark Dantonio.
Greg Roman, offensive coordinator, San Francisco 49ers – Considering the success of David Shaw at Stanford and Willie Taggart at Western Kentucky, Roman is the next Jim Harbaugh assistant to land a head coaching gig. The New Jersey native has no head coaching experience but has stops as an NFL assistant with the Panthers, Ravens and Texans. Roman also worked with Harbaugh at Stanford and helped to coordinate one of the nation’s best offenses. One downside to Roman’s candidacy has to be the 49ers’ playoff chances. With San Francisco likely to make a deep run into the NFL playoffs, Roman may not be available on a full-time basis until mid-January.
Mario Cristobal, former FIU head coach
Luke Fickell, co-defensive coordinator, Ohio State
Todd Monken, offensive coordinator, Oklahoma State