2012 Quarterback Rankings: Big 12

Unpublished

Get the Athlon Sports Newsletter

Looming decisions for Griffin III, Jones and the courts will play major role in 2012.

<p> Looming decisions for Griffin III, Jones and the courts will play major role in 2012.</p>

-by Braden Gall (follow at @BradenGall)

There is no doubt this is the Era of the Quarterback.

Houston’s Case Keenum (152) and Boise State’s Kellen Moore (142) both broke Graham Harrell’s all-time NCAA touchdown record of 134 scoring strikes this season. Keenum also became the NCAA’s all-time record holder for total offense (19,572) and passing yards (18,685). Moore, meanwhile, is the NCAA’s all-time winningest quarterback with a 50-3 record as a starter. And because Keenum still has one game left to go, he could conceivably reach 20,000 yards of total offense (think about that).

Baylor’s Robert Griffin III and Wisconsin’s Russell Wilson both need efficient showings in bowl games to break Colt Brennan’s NCAA single-season passer efficiency record of 186.0. And Wilson broke Harrell’s record of consecutive games with a touchdown pass with 37.

In the unbalanced college game, there are many different ways to evaluate quarterback play. Gifted runners, crazy schemes, talent differentials, level of competition and raw NFL talent all become a part of the equation. The bottom line is the quarterback is the single most important position on the field, and having a great one under center can take a mediocre football team and elevate it to title contender (just ask Wisconsin).

So who will boast the best signal callers in college football next fall? Athlon Sports takes a very early stab at ranking quarterback play in 2012 by conference:

2012 Quarterback Rankings:

1. Pac-12: Barkley, Thomas and Price Lead the Way
2. ACC: The Deepest QB Conference in Football
3. Big 12: Big Decisions Looming For RG3, Jones
4. SEC: Best League Adds Mizzou's Franklin, Texas A&M
5. Big Ten: The Nation's Most Athletic Quarterbacks
6. Big East: Uncertainty Reigns Supreme Again

3. Big 12

If all things fall into place, this league is easily the No. 3 conference on this list. But that is a big if, as Robert Griffin III and Landry Jones each have a difficult decisions to make. Jones won’t be a first-round selection and is more likely to return than RG3 — who is a near lock for the top half of the first round. It would be a major "upset" if both were to return to school.

The good news, however, is that should both leave for the NFL, West Virginia (if allowed) and TCU will bring with them excellent quarterbacks in Geno Smith and Casey Pachall. Each tossed 25 touchdowns and only seven interceptions in 2011. Smith led his team to a conference championship and a BCS bowl this season, while Pachall finished the regular season seventh in the nation in passing efficiency after taking over for TCU legend Andy Dalton.

Kansas State’s Collin Klein is simply a winner, and his ability to take over a game on the ground can be remarkable to watch. He topped the 1,000-yard mark rushing and scored 26 times on the ground — one short of the NCAA single-season mark for a quarterback with a bowl game still to go. Texas Tech’s Seth Doege began the year with seven straight 300-yard efforts, tailed off, and then posted big games in the season’s final two contests. His numbers were very impressive, but the 2-7 conference record was not.

The rest of the league is a big unknown. David Ash played well in the Holliday Bowl win over Cal and may have the inside track on the starting job in 2012 for Texas. Inexplicably, none of the Horns’ numerous elite prep quarterbacks have panned out. A year after changing his coordinators, Mack Brown must make progress at the quarterback position if he expects to compete next fall.

Charlie Weis and Kansas are importing talent left and right and will have Notre Dame transfer Dayne Crist starting next fall before BYU transfer Jake Heaps takes over in 2013. Jared Barnett played well for Iowa State down the stretch but is anything but entrenched in Ames. And it is the next man up in Stillwater, where Mike Gundy simply plugs in another productive name every year. That said, replacing Brandon Weeden won't be as easy as replacing Zac Robinson.

Should WVU be allowed to compete, and Jones and Griffin III return, this will once again be one of the best quarterbacked leagues in the nation. But should the conference "lose" all three (as well as Weeden), there will be a serious lack of depth at this position with major question marks at key programs. Is Nick Florence ready at Baylor? Blake Bell or Drew Allen in Norman? Can Clint Chelf keep the Pokes train rolling?

We will know a lot more about this league come spring practice.

The Known Commodities:

1. Robert Griffin III, Baylor (SR)*
Passing Stats: 3,998 yards, 36 TD, 6 INT, 72.4%
Rushing Stats: 161 att., 644 yards, 9 TD

2. Landry Jones, Oklahoma (SR)*
Passing Stats: 4,302 yards, 28 TD, 14 INT, 63.1%
Rushing Stats: 28 att., minus-16 yards, 2 TD

3. Geno Smith, West Virginia (SR)**
Passing Stats: 3,978 yards, 25 TD, 7 INT, 65.0%
Rushing Stats: 51 att., minus-59 yards, TD

4. Collin Klein, Kansas State (SR)
Passing Stats: 1,745 yards, 12 TD, 5 INT, 57.8%
Rushing Stats: 293 att., 1,099 yards, 26 TD

5. Casey Pachall, TCU (JR)
Passing Stats: 2,972 yards, 25 TD, 7 INT, 66.5%
Rushing Stats: 68 att., 51 yards, 2 TD

6. Seth Doege, Texas Tech (SR)
Passing Stats: 4,004 yards, 28 TD, 10 INT, 68.5%
Rushing Stats: 54 att., 46 yards, 4 TD

7. Jared Barnett, Iowa State (SO)
Passing Stats: 1,178 yards, 6 TD, 6 INT, 50.7%
Rushing Stats: 99 att., 435 yards, TD

* - could elect to enter the NFL Draft
* - may not be permitted to compete in the Big 12

The Unknowns:

David Ash/Case McCoy/Connor Brewer, Texas
Clint Chelf/Wes Lunt, Oklahoma State
Dayne Crist/Jordan Webb, Kansas
Blake Bell/Drew Allen, Oklahoma
Nick Florence, Baylor

2012 Quarterback Rankings:

1. Pac-12: Barkley, Thomas and Price Lead the Way
2. ACC: The Deepest QB Conference in Football
3. Big 12: Big Decisions Looming For RG3, Jones
4. SEC: Best League Adds Mizzou's Franklin, Texas A&M
5. Big Ten: The Nation's Most Athletic Quarterbacks
6. Big East: Uncertainty Reigns Supreme Again

CFB Conferences: 

Home Page Infinite Scroll Left