Get the Athlon Sports Newsletter
The Sooners and Bob Stoops put together the top class in the Big 12.
Rivals.com, Scout.com, ESPN and 247Sports.com are the four major recruiting services who all do an excellent job evaluating, tracking and ranking all things recruiting.
But they don't always agree and that is a great thing for fans. It also means the best way to rank the best classes in the nation is to average them all together and come to a consensus. One service may value quantity while another may value quality. One service may really love one prospect while another may not feel as strongly about him. Each site has its own metric for evaluating a class. Again, this is why Athlon Sports publishes its national team recruiting rankings as an average of the four big sites combined.
After another stellar National Signing Day of winners and losers, here are the consensus Big 12 team rankings for 2014 — with familiar names atop the standings.
• The Sooners and Longhorns paced the Big 12 once again but neither was as strong (pardon the pun) as they are accustomed to being. Oklahoma's 13th-rated class nationally would be eighth in the SEC, third in the ACC and second in the Big Ten and Pac-12. Texas would be the same except third in the Pac-12. These two powerhouses have to be clicking on all cylinders on the trail for the Big 12 to be at its best.
• Overall, the league hasn't signed elite talent since Colorado, Nebraska, Texas A&M and Missouri left the ranks. In 2014, the Big 12 signed two five-star prospects and 29 four-star prospects. The Aggies alone inked three five-star while the SEC signed 119 four-star recruits. The Big 12 landed seven top-100 players this year after just four last year and six the previous cycle. The Big 12 is improving across the board with great coaches but the nation's most elite players don't appear to be interested.
• Bill Snyder finished eighth in the Big 12... again. And he doesn't care... again. The Wildcats ranked outside of the top 50 nationally in recruiting for the sixth consecutive cycle with the 2007 class — ranked 30th — being the last Kansas State group to land inside the top 50. Yet, somehow, Snyder is one of the winningest coaches in the league — his 27 conference wins since returning to Manhattan in 2009 rank third in the Big 12 behind Stoops and Gundy.
• There were some rumors that Mack Brown, on his way "out" of town, told his class of players to look around at other options. So Charlie Strong, in theory, had to recruit against his own school over the first month of his tenure. The Longhorns had a solid class, ranking 15th nationally, but Strong did very little on the recruiting trail over the last month despite big promises at his press conference. The 2015 haul will be intriguing to watch from the outside looking in.
• Kliff Kingsbury and Texas Tech were the only team in the league that didn't sign at least one four-star recruit. He brought in a big (27) group filled entirely of three- and two-star recruits that landed in the top 40 nationally. Everyone knows he is confident and believes in his system but can Tech contend against the big boys in Austin and Norman with nary a four-star player?
• One class that experts can't seem to agree on is Oklahoma State. Scout is much higher on Mike Gundy's group than the other three sites, ranking them 14th in the nation as the Big 12's second-best class. However, 247, Rivals and ESPN had the Pokes at 27th or 28th nationally and both 247 and ESPN had OSU ranked fourth in the conference. Only time will tell who is right about Oklahoma State's '14 haul.