Mark Dantonio wasn't the only one with a strange ballot
For the last time, the coaches’ poll and Harris poll will factor into the national championship.
The end of the BCS means the end of the coaches’ poll as a component of postseason selection and the end of the Harris Interactive top 25 altogether.
For that, college football fans should be relieved.
Whatever their intentions, both polls ended up with their share of voters who made bizarre choices for their rankings. A disregard to head-to-head records, conference favoritism and voters who may or may not have paid attention to the season infiltrated the final polls year after year.
Granted, a majority of the voters probably made an honest effort and could justify their ballots with well-thought out data and observations.
The others, though ... it's fun to point and laugh sometimes.
Here’s what we found when the ballots were released late Sunday.
Inside the coaches’ poll (link to every ballot)
• Eight coaches did not start their polls with Florida State, Auburn and Alabama in that order. Michigan State coach Mark Dantonio voted his team second, ahead of Auburn and Alabama. Can you blame him? West Virginia coach Dana Holgorsen also voted Michigan State second for reasons unknown.
• Virginia Tech coach Frank Beamer, Louisiana-Lafayette coach Mark Hudspeth and South Carolina coach Steve Spurrier voted Florida State and Auburn first and second but Michigan State third. Texas Tech coach Kliff Kingsbury voted FSU and Auburn and then Baylor, a team in the same league and led by another coach from Texas Tech stock. Washington State coach Mike Leach voted Stanford third
• Arkansas coach Bret Bielema, ever the pot-stirrer, voted Ohio State at No. 12, the Buckeyes' lowest ranking. Bielema did vote his former team Wisconsin at No. 21 despite Badgers’ fans ire at his departure. Bielema also gave Louisville its highest ranking at No. 6.
• Steve Spurrier for years gave Duke the No. 25 spot on his preseason ballot as a thank you to the Blue Devils for giving him his first head coaching job. USA Today eventually told him to knock it off to protect the integrity of the poll. Now given a chance to vote for Duke for real, Spurrier gave the Blue Devils their highest rank at No. 16.
• Virginia Tech coach Frank Beamer was not totally impressed with the SEC this season, ranking Missouri 14th and LSU 15th. Both were ranked behind the top three teams in the Big 12 (Baylor, Oklahoma and Oklahoma State) and top two teams in the American (UCF and Louisville).
• Baylor coach Art Briles was quite the Big 12 homer, voting Baylor fourth, Oklahoma State sixth and Oklahoma seventh. That came at the expensive of No. 8 Michigan State and No. 11 Missouri.
• The coaches’ poll as a whole did not peg UCF ahead of Louisville until the final week of the season (UCF beat Louisville 38-35 on Oct 18). Arizona State coach Todd Graham didn’t get the memo, voting Louisville ninth and UCF 22nd. For the record, UCF coach George O’Leary and Louisville coach Charlie Strong both voted the Knights higher.
• Washington State coach Mike Leach was even less of a fan of the American Athletic Conference with UCF at No. 24 and Louisville at No. 25. Leach also gave Oregon its highest ranking at No. 6.
• Texas State coach Dennis Franchione had two MAC teams on his ballot, neither of which won the championship. Franchione voted Ball State 24th and Northern Illinois 25th.
• Other evidence of conference favoritism: Dantonio tacked Iowa and Minnesota at the end of his ballot, Florida State coach Jimbo Fisher gave his last two votes to Miami and Virginia Tech, Marshall coach Doc Holliday made room for C-USA champion Rice at No. 24.
• Where coaches voted their own teams (final ranking in parentheses):
David Bailiff, Rice, NR (also receiving votes)
Art Briles, Baylor, No. 4 (No. 5)
Rod Carey, Northern Illinois, No. 13 (No. 23)
Dave Clawson, Bowling Green, No. 25 (also receiving votes)
David Cutcliffe, Duke, No. 20 (No. 21)
Mark Dantonio, Michigan State, No. 2 (No. 4)
Tim DeRuyter, Fresno State, No. 18 (No. 20)
Jimbo Fisher, No. 1 (No. 1)
James Franklin, Vanderbilt, No. 23 (also receiving votes)
Al Golden, Miami, No. 24 (No. 25)
Todd Graham, Arizona State, No. 14 (No. 17)
Mike Gundy, Oklahoma State, No. 10 (No. 13)
Mark Helfrich, Oregon, No. 7 (No. 12)
Brian Kelly, Notre Dame, No. 25 (also receiving votes)
Jerry Kill, Minnesota, No. 25 (also receiving votes)
Urban Meyer, Ohio State, No. 5 (No. 6)
Les Miles, LSU, No. 11 (No. 14)
George O’Leary, UCF, No. 12 (No. 15)
Mark Richt, Georgia, No. 20 (No. 24)
Nick Saban, Alabama, No. 3 (No. 3)
Steve Spurrier, South Carolina, No. 7 (No. 8)
Bob Stoops, Oklahoma, No. 9 (No. 10)
Charlie Strong, Louisville, No. 12 (No. 16)
Kevin Sumlin, Texas A&M, No. 20 (No. 21)
Dabo Swinney, Clemson, No. 9 (No. 11)
Tommy Tuberville, Cincinnati, No. 25 (also receiving votes)
Inside the Harris poll (link to every ballot)
Related: Identifying every voter in the Harris poll
• Auburn received eight first-place votes, becoming the only other team besides Florida State to be ranked No. 1. Among those who voted Auburn first were Kansas City Chiefs general manager John Dorsey and former Michigan coach Lloyd Carr.
• Auburn, though, hasn’t convinced everyone in the Harris poll. Jack Ebling, a host for WVFB in Lansing, Mich., voted Alabama second, one spot ahead of Auburn, despite the Tigers’ victory on a last-second missed field goal returned for a touchdown.
• How much did Ohio State’s 34-24 loss in the Michigan State hurt the Buckeyes’ stock? Seven voters dropped Ohio State to No. 10 or lower after the Buckeyes were second in the poll before the championship game. A few of these must have taken into account the weakness of the Big Ten as five of the seven ranked Michigan State lower than the rest of the poll. Former Notre Dame player Derrick Mayes ranked Ohio State 13th and Michigan State 11th. Former Army player Bob Anderson ranked Ohio State 12th and Michigan State eighth.
• For four voters, it’s as if the Big Ten championship game never happened. The following voted Ohio State ahead of Michigan State:
Bob Grim, former Oregon State player: No. 4 Ohio State, No. 9 Michigan State
Mike McGee, former Cincinnati and USC athletic director: No. 5 Ohio State, No. 6 Michigan State
Jordan Palmer, former UTEP quarterback: No. 4 Ohio State, No. 5 Michigan State
Riley Skinner, former Wake Forest quarterback: No. 4 Ohio State, No. 6 Michigan State
• Speaking of blatant disregard for head-to-head results among teams with similar records, 19 voters kept Oklahoma State ahead of Oklahoma despite identical records and the Sooners’ 33-24 win in Stillwater. Former Texas player Denny Aldridge ranked the Cowboys a full eight spots ahead of Oklahoma (No. 8 and No. 16).
• At least former South Alabama athletic director Joe Gottfried paid attention to Bedlam: He ranked Oklahoma sixth ... and Baylor ninth. Baylor won the Big 12 in part by beating Oklahoma 41-12 on Nov. 7.
• Former UAB broadcaster Gary Sanders turned in one of the strangest ballots with Louisville as high as No. 7. But the most eye-catching ranking was UCLA at No. 12. He found room for Pac-12 South champion Arizona State at No. 25.
• Sanders was one of 36 voters to rank UCLA ahead of Arizona State. The Sun Devils beat the Bruins 38-35 in the Rose Bowl to clinch the Pac-12 South.
• One storyline of the season was Louisville remaining ahead of UCF despite the Knights’ 38-35 win on the road over the Cardinals. UCF’s win, plus an edge in the non-conference schedule that included a win at Penn State and three-point loss to South Carolina, didn’t swing the 39 voters who kept Louisville ranked ahead of UCF in the final poll. Five voters ranked Louisville at least seven spots higher than UCF: former West Virginia player John Mallory, former Cal player Craig Morton, former UAB broadcaster Gary Sanders, former Kentucky player Jeff Van Note and former Louisville player Dwayne Woodruff.
• Dwayne Woodruff’s No. 8 ranking of his alma mater Louisville aside, favoritism didn’t appear to be too rampant in the final Harris poll. One notable exception: Former Fresno State athletic director Scott Johnson voted the Bulldogs 12th. Fresno State was ranked 20th in the final poll.
• Among the more, shall we say, interesting ballots:
Former Miami and Kentucky coach Fran Curci voted Baylor fourth, Louisville, eighth, Miami 17th, Rice 19th and Arizona State 24th ... while leaving Texas A&M and Georgia unranked.
Former Stanford quarterback Todd Husak ranked Oregon eighth, Arizona State 13th, UCLA 16th and Washington 25th.
Bob Marcum, former athletic director at Kansas, South Carolina and Marshall, voted Fresno State 13th, Northern Illinois 15th and Duke 16th ... all ahead of Clemson, Oregon, LSU and Arizona State.
Former Notre Dame player Derrick Mayes ranked Missouri fourth, South Carolina fifth, Clemson sixth, Oregon eighth, Michigan State 11th, Louisville 12th and Ohio State 13th.
Jim Walden, a former coach at Iowa State and Washington State, ranked both UCF (sixth) and Louisville (eighth) in the top 10 at the expense of South Carolina and Missouri. South Carolina defeated UCF 28-25 in Orlando.