Despite his assurances, Cutler was a fantasy football dud.
We fell for it and we could not have been any angrier watching that disaster of a fantasy, er, football game Thursday night as the Green Bay Packers beat the Chicago Bears, 23-10.
We fell for Jay Cutler’s Tuesday presser this week where he told us “this is a totally different scheme, a mentality and direction that we’re going offensively.”
Why didn’t we just see it right there?
He all but told us he was the same Cutler, just with a healthy thumb now.
Totally different scheme, mentality and direction could have been looked at as where the offense goes from here under new offensive coordinator Mike Tice and quarterbacks coach Jeremy Bates. After all, it’s Tice who was set to get a true ground game going in Chicago and Bates who coached Cutler for three seasons in Denver.
In hindsight, it looks like Cutler again placing blame where he always has — elsewhere.
Cutler was cocky and confident on Tuesday. He invited press coverage; he invited man coverage from the Packers.
Yes, my heart believed while my mind was telling me: “You know better than this.”
But it was all there for the taking.
We saw Green Bay’s last-ranked pass defense from a year ago that showed up at home in Week One and allowed San Francisco’s Alex Smith to throw for a pedestrian 211 yards but on 20-of-26 passing with two scores and no interceptions.
We saw Cutler’s two new weapons — Brandon Marshall (6-5) and Alshon Jeffery (6-3) going against smaller cornerbacks Tramon Williams (5-11) and Jarrett Bush (6-0). He even has his old Vanderbilt buddy, Earl Bennett, to run around the middle of the field and make plays.
But numbers are numbers are numbers. We don’t even care that he was 1-5 in six starts against Green Bay; this is fantasy football. However, Cutler had completed just 56.9 percent of his passes for 240.2 yards per outing with 11 interceptions and seven scores going into Thursday’s game. That’s terrible.
And if that’s terrible, what’s this?: 11-of-27 for 126 yards, one TD and four interceptions. Well, that’s just “same old Jay” as Packers defensive back Charles Woodson said after the game.
Why didn’t it just register in my mind that Cutler was 1-for-10 for 13 yards before elite pass rusher Dwight Freeney went out of the game last week against the Indianapolis? I’m pretty sure 32nd-ranked pass defense or not, the Packers have more to offer in the form of pressure than the Colts do.
But there we were, holding out hope much like Cutler was holding on to the ball for….ev…..er.
It may be said that Thursday night was a result of his offensive line, the drops from his receivers or that running back Matt Forte went out with an ankle injury in the third quarter. But it’s always going to be something with Cutler.
With this performance fresh in our minds, it is easy to be beyond pessimistic on what Cutler has in store as a fantasy QB the rest of the way.
Next up are the Rams, Cowboys and Jaguars before a bye. He returns to face the Lions, Panthers, Titans, Texans and 49ers.
Call us pessimistic.
Look at the numbers see that Cutler was only a top-10 fantasy quarterback on three occasions last season and a top-12 in only four outings. On three occasions he was 24th or worse. He reached as high as fifth in his last game before the thumb injury but that came a week after he was 31st.
That about sums it up, don’t you think?
Cutler will get his some weeks. But with games against Dallas, Detroit, Houston, San Francisco and Carolina, yes, even Carolina where he finished 32nd amongst QBs when he faced them last year, he just can’t be trusted as a weekly starter.
Perhaps he will put it together against the likes of the Rams and Jaguars and Titans and you can trust him again. But then fate and Packers rear their heads again as he gets Green Bay again in the fantasy semifinals Week 15.
In the words of Jay Cutler this week: “Good luck.”
— By Corby A. Yarbrough, @Corby_Yarbrough on Twitter