NFL Scouts Talk Anonymously About NFC East Teams

Get the Athlon Sports Newsletter

Scouts discuss Chip Kelly's Eagles, as well as the Cowboys, Giants and Redskins

NFL Scouts Talk Anonymously About NFC East Teams

NFC East champion Philadelphia was the only team in the division to finish with a winning record last season. Now that defensive coordinators have had an offseason to study Chip Kelly’s offense, will the Eagles have as much success in 2014 or will there be a new No. 1? Between Dallas, New York and Washington, which team is best positioned to challenge the Eagles’ divisional supremacy and contend for a playoff spot?

 

In order to get an accurate assessment of how the NFC East looks entering the 2014 season, Athlon asked NFL scouts to talk anonymously about the Cowboys, Giants, Eagles and Redskins.

 

Note: These scouting reports come directly from NFL scouts and do not necessarily reflect the views of Athlon's editorial staff. 

 

Dallas Cowboys

 

“The truth is the Cowboys have won when Jerry Jones hired Jimmy Johnson and Bill Parcells and allowed them to run the football part of the organization. Barry Switzer lived off the gas that was left in the tank by Jimmy and Wade Phillips kept it afloat to a degree after Bill left. The 136-136 won/loss record since 1996 says it all, a mediocre team that is marketed as well as any professional organization in all of sports.” …

 

“In recent years, they have been so cap-strapped that there is little that could be done via free agency and their drafts have only been marginally productive.” …

 

“Tony Romo gets all the blame, but in reality, he hasn’t gotten much help from his run game or defense. He’s coming off back surgery and that’s always tricky, however, all indications are that he will be fine for 2014.” …

 

“DeMarco Murray was injury-prone at OU and that trend has continued in Dallas, as he has missed 11 of 48 career games. When healthy, he is capable and provides some cover for Romo.” …

 

“Jason Witten continues to be a solid pro, but he has slowed down some in terms of run-after-the-catch, so the Cowboys are really hoping that last year’s second- rounder, Gavin Escobar, will take a huge step forward this year.” …

 

“Say what you will about Dez Bryant, but it does appear that he has matured on and off the field and is an absolute house to cover and tackle when he is engaged and into the game. Terrance Williams had an excellent rookie campaign and was a great value choice in the third round last spring. Dwayne Harris would be the slot if the season started tomorrow.” …

 

“On the offensive line, Tyron Smith enters his fourth season and has developed nicely into a prominent left tackle. The Travis Frederick pick was criticized at the time, however, he had a good rookie year and should only get better in the future. Doug Free has found a home at RT. Expect first round pick Zack Martin to find a starting role at one of the guard spots with the possibility of playing tackle, if necessary.” …

 

“Use any adjective to describe it, but ugly may be at the top of the list when it comes to describing the Cowboys’ defense in 2013. Wow, was this group bad and the stats don’t lie either: 32nd in yardage allowed, 26th in points allowed and 29th in third-down conversions.” ….

 

“Monte Kiffin was re-assigned and one of his pupils, Rod Marinelli, was brought in to be the coordinator.” …

 

“They added Henry Melton from Chicago, but he is coming off a knee injury and the rest of this defensive line may be as anonymous as any in the league.” …

 

“Second-round pick DeMarcus Lawrence (Boise State) is being counted on heavily to pressure the QB in 2014.” …

 

“Sean Lee is a nice player, but he has suffered through some injury situations [Editor’s note: Lee is out for the season after tearing his ACL during OTAs in May], while Bruce Carter has yet to his athletic potential and Justin Durant is on his third team.” …

 

“Dallas has not gotten the return-on-investment hoped for at the cornerback positions. Brandon Carr signed for huge money from Kansas City, but is not a shutdown corner, and Mo Claiborne was probably over drafted at No. 6 in 2012, based on the way he has played in the past two years.” …

 

“The corners actually look OK when compared to the safeties. Barry Church has made himself into a player from being undrafted and J.J. Wilcox has only played defense for two seasons, so there is an upside to him.” …

 

“This defense has so far to go against the run and pass that if they can improve just slightly, it could take some wear off Romo and maybe give the organization a legit shot of getting over the hump and into the playoffs.” ...

 

New York Giants

 

“In many ways without changing the GM and head coach, the Giants moved away from their conservative philosophy and fired coaches and delved into free agency heavily to try and shake up their own franchise.” …

 

“Tom Coughlin got rid of long-time offensive coordinator Kevin Gilbride and hired Ben McAdoo from Green Bay to call plays, while rather than waiting on the draft, GM Jerry Reese was active in signing at least 10 significant free agents.” …

 

“Still, the bottom line here is the play of Eli Manning. His 27 interceptions led the league and the turnover margin killed any chance of this team making the playoffs a year ago.” …

 

“McAdoo will install a more disciplined attack based on timing and reads and that adjustment may rejuvenate Manning mentally and physically.” ....

 

“Odell Beckham, Jr. was their first-round pick and he is really a good player. Along with Victor Cruz and Reuben Randle, they can now get a threat to all parts of the field.” …

 

“in 2013, with the line struggling up front, defenses could double those two and still squeeze off the run game. Will Beatty has been a disaster at LT, Chris Snee has gotten old [Editor’s note: Snee retired prior to the start of training camp.] and Justin Pugh had his rookie season ups-and-downs. They signed Geoff Schwartz from KC to help secure the inside of the pocket, but OGs are not game-changers.” …

 

“Defensive coordinator Perry Fewell has lost some of his luster, but it’s primarily been because of Jason Pierre-Paul’s lack of production due to injuries. They need him to return to form, in addition to Damontre Moore or newly acquired Robert Ayers to provide some pass rush from the opposite side.” …

 

“The linebacker unit is a collection of average players and they inked Jameel McClain from the Ravens despite his neck injury in December.” …

 

“It’s Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie to the rescue at corner and that is surprising because of his struggles with the Eagles back in 2011 and ’12. Prince Amukamara was over-drafted, so he will never be a lockdown corner. Walter Thurmond was brought in from Seattle as a third corner. In the meantime, Antrel Rolle is arguably the best player on the team right now.” …

 

“Two Super Bowls will buy a GM and head coach almost as much time as they want, but there is no question that 2014 is an important year for Coughlin and Reese and almost all of the results will come from the right arm of Eli Manning, because this team is really average everywhere else.” …

 

Philadelphia Eagles

 

“Many in the NFL felt the Chip Kelly experiment would be a boom-or-bust proposition, and so far, it’s been a big hit.” …

 

“Kelly managed the Riley Cooper situation during camp with the aplomb of a veteran pro coach and then had complete buy-in on his innovative scheme that resulted in the Eagles being second in total offense.” …

 

“it’s now obvious that offensive line play is a huge key for them, because they essentially locked up all five starters through the 2016 season and then released Pro Bowl receiver DeSean Jackson on March 28. The reaction from the players was surprising, but not a shock, they know the deal on DJax, he can be petulant, but make up for it on Sundays. Then again, despite his career-best numbers, he disappeared at times and is a WR at 5-10/175 that has to be ‘schemed’ open, unlike the classic 6’-/215 No. 1 receiver.” …

 

“Jeremy Maclin returns from an ACL, Cooper was inked to a five-year deal and Jordan Matthews (Vanderbilt) and Josh Huff (Oregon) are expected to contribute as rookies this year.” …

 

“Brent Celek has always been under-appreciated and Zach Ertz really showed up during the back half of the season.” …

 

“With the trade for Darren Sproles, combined with the skill set of LeSean McCoy, Kelly can really get creative with his 12 and 22 personnel groupings.” …

 

“And all of this is said without even mentioning Nick Foles who replaced Michael Vick and threw 27 touchdowns against only two interceptions. Foles surprised even his proponents with his sterling play in 2013.” The question will be how much opposing defenses adjust and take away some of his strengths after an offseason of evaluation.” …

 

“Regardless, for the Eagles to advance beyond the first round of the playoffs, it’s all about their defense. The front seven has been reshaped into a 3-4 with Fletcher Cox and Mychal Kendricks being two young players to really build around. Cox began to take to the scheme down the stretch and Kendricks is as explosive of a linebacker that is currently in the league.” …

 

“Trent Cole has tapered off some over the last three campaigns and Connor Barwin is actually better against the run than as a pass-rusher, which equated to the Eagles drafting OLB Marcus Smith (Louisville) in the first round.” …

 

“The secondary is their biggest weakness and that’s because of shaky play on the outsides and in the deep middle. Bradley Fletcher is ‘just a guy’ and Cary Williams thinks he’s better than he is, which can be a problem when trying to play within the system.” …

 

“Brandon Boykin had a terrific season as the nickelback and the Eagles signed Malcolm Jenkins as a veteran safety with some coverage ability. Eagles’ insiders feel good about Earl Wolff, and again, some of their defensive problems go back to a lack of pass rush.” …

 

“Now that the league’s coordinators have had a chance to study this Eagles offense, Kelly will have to show his adaptability in creating new ways to sustain the kind of success they enjoyed last year, but he earned a ton of respect within the league a season ago.” …

 

Washington Redskins

 

“It’s not a small thing that the Redskins fired the Shanahans, but kept GM Bruce Allen and defensive coordinator Jim Haslett, because it keeps a semblance of continuity within the organization and puts the focus on repairing Robert Griffin III as a long-term NFL quarterback.” …

 

“Allen tapped into his Gruden tree and hired Jay as the new head coach and the person most responsible for turning around RGIII.” …

 

“One of the biggest moves of the offseason occurred when the NFC East rival Eagles released DeSean Jackson. It didn’t take Washington long to get him in their building and on the roster. With Pierre Garcon coming off a career year and Andre Roberts signing in March, this will be a versatile set of wide receivers.” …

 

“If TE Jordan Reed can return from injury, Griffin should have ample opportunity to spread the football around in Gruden’s offensive system.” …

 

“Alfred Morris probably takes a step back in this scheme, but he is capable and a workhorse style of ball-carrier.” …

 

“If the game was 7-on-7, the Redskins would be near the top of the league, unfortunately, it does take an offensive line and that is a major concern. Trent Williams can certainly play, but Shawn Lauvao had problems in Cleveland and Kory Lichtensteiger will be shifted to center from OG. Chris Chester is OK at right guard and Tyler Polumbus is a tall, stiff right tackle that is only ordinary.” …

 

“Defensively, this unit struggled for much of the 2013 season. They added Jason Hatcher from the Cowboys in free agency, but need much more from Jarvis Jenkins and others along the front.” …

 

“Outside linebackers Ryan Kerrigan and Brian Orakpo must get untracked this year for them to have any shot of getting off the field on third down. Perry Riley is underrated on the inside and Darryl Sharpton was inked from Houston, but the loss of London Fletcher will be significant.” …

 

“That’s why Ryan Clark was brought in from Pittsburgh and the hope is he can coordinate things in the back end and help develop Phillip Thomas and/or Bacarri Rambo. DeAngelo Hall is now 30, but can still play some, while David Amerson is a Cover 2-style corner with length. They should be worried about their Sub package slot corners.” …

 

“Inside the Beltway, it’s all about RGIII getting a full offseason and adapting to Gruden’s system. If that happens and no major injuries occur, this team can compete in the NFC East. In the meantime, the RGMe-to-MeSean Show will be one to watch.” ...

NFL Conferences: 
NFL Divisions: 
Exclude From Games: 
Include In Games
Previous Article: 
NFL Scouts Talk Anonymously About NFC South Teams

More Stories:

Home Page Infinite Scroll Left