Skip to main content

Andrew Luck vs. LSU or Alabama


Stanford’s Andrew Luck may be the best quarterback prospect since the forward pass was popularized. Or at least since Peyton Manning came out in 1998. Maybe since fellow Cardinal John Elway was drafted in 1983.

LSU at Alabama is the game of the century. The Tigers and Tide are clearly the top two teams in the country. Les Miles and Nick Saban have the most NFL talent, the best athletes and the scariest defenses in the land.

How great would it be to have everyone’s All-American take the ultimate test in a bowl game against either LSU or Alabama in his final collegiate game?

The Cardinal have a shot at playing the winner of LSU-Alabama in the BCS title game if they can survive Oregon (Nov. 12) and Notre Dame (Nov. 26) visits on the Farm. But there is an outside chance Luck could still square off against the LSU-Alabama loser if Oregon takes down Stanford and the Ducks fly to Pasadena as the Pac-12 rep in the Rose Bowl.

Luck has a 28–5 record as a starter at Stanford, but has never played a team from the SEC, and definitely hasn’t faced the type of next-level power and speed that both LSU and Alabama bring to the field every Saturday.

Win or lose, Luck vs. LSU or Alabama would be the perfect parting shot for the hyperbolic prospect.

Several NFL fan bases are hoping to “Suck for Luck” — or lose as many games as possible — in order to land the No. 1 overall pick in the 2012 NFL Draft and a chance to select the 6'4", 235-pound franchise quarterback whose off-the-charts measurables and intangibles are rarely seen even once in a generation.

The 22-year-old Houston native is the son of a former NFL quarterback, current West Virginia athletic director Oliver Luck. He was also mentored by another former NFL signal-caller, former Cardinal coach and current San Francisco 49ers boss Jim Harbaugh.

Extremely advanced for his age, the fourth-year junior calls his own plays — a la Manning — for first-year Stanford coach David Shaw. Under the leadership of Luck, the Cardinal have won a school-record 16 straight games, which is also the nation’s longest active winning streak.

Last season, Luck was runner-up to Auburn quarterback Cam Newton in Heisman Trophy voting after completing 70.7 percent of his passes for 3,338 yards, 32 TDs and eight INTs — capping a 12–1 season with a 40–12 win over Virginia Tech in the Orange Bowl. This season, Luck has completed 71.9 percent of his passes for 2,218 yards, 23 TDs and four INTs, leading Stanford to an 8–0 start.

Most recently, Luck carried Stanford to a 56–48 triple-overtime win over USC at the L.A. Coliseum. Although the Trojans have an NFL coaching staff and a defense led by Tampa 2 legend Monte Kiffin, this is not Pete Carroll’s wall-to-wall first-round roster at USC. Even Lane Kiffin, whose SEC coaching career lasted just one season at Tennessee, would have to admit the Trojans don’t have the horses that the Bayou Bengals and Crimson Tide do.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

In one of his more impressive outings, Luck completed 29-of-40 passes for 330 yards, three TDs and one INT, which was returned for a pick-six that gave Southern Cal a 34–27 lead with 3:08 left in the fourth quarter. But Luck rallied the troops, marching the Cardinal down the field on a 12-play, 76-yard drive to tie the game at 34–34 with 38 seconds remaining.

“We put the ball in our quarterback’s hands, put it on his shoulders,” said Shaw, “and the kid came through.”

Luck’s maturity and ability to handle adversity have fans across the NFL crossing their fingers for a passer and person that those around him can’t seem to praise enough.

“I’m running out of things to say. He’s like a vitamin. Once a day. Once a day, he does something that makes you say, ‘Wow.’ It’s been ‘once a day’ for four years,” said Shaw, who worked with the redshirt junior quarterback as an offensive coordinator before taking over as Stanford’s head coach.

“You get tired of saying, ‘Nice throw. You get tired of saying, ‘Good read.’ You get tired of saying, ‘Nice job in the pocket.’ ‘Nice job escaping.’ ‘Good decision.’ You know he gets tired of hearing it. We get to the point where I try not to compliment him too much. The problem is, there are not a lot of flaws.”

Phil Simms would disagree. The Super Bowl XXI MVP came as close to ripping Luck as anyone has when he spoke with Adam Schein and Rich Gannon on SiriusXM NFL Radio.

“I just don’t see big time NFL throws. I don’t care what anybody says. I’ve watched a lot of him. He never takes it and rips it in there. And you can say what you want but, man, you’ve got to be able to crease that ball every once in a while,” said Simms, a CBS analyst and father of two quarterbacks, Chris and Matt.

“There’s not a lot of rotation on the ball and there’s not a tremendous amount of power. Not that you need to have that power arm. I’m not saying you’ve got to have that exclusively but, man, it sure helps when you can do that because there’s four or five plays a game it is about arm strength. …

“What’s he going to do to match what they say he can do?”

How about marching the ball on an LSU or Alabama defense? Or zipping the pill past a closing first-round cornerback like Morris Claiborne or Dre Kirkpatrick? Or upsetting the heavily-favored Tigers or Tide? Maybe even for the BCS national title?

It’s early; but that could be the next “game of the century.”

by Nathan Rush