The merits of recruiting rankings are debated in every sports bar and around every water cooler in the nation. Athlon continues its look back at recruiting rankings by comparing the starting line-ups in the BCS National Championship Game as recruits.
2012 Alabama's Starting Offenses as Recruits
A.J. McCarron, QB (2009) AC100
Alabama landed one of the nation’s top signal-callers when it inked McCarron back in 2009, and it showed in his SEC leading 66.7% completion rate in his first year under center. The lanky passer was the No. 8-rated QB prospect in the nation and was the No. 97 overall player in the '09 Athlon Consensus 100. Bad chest tattoo aside, Bama landed a good one when it beat out Miami, Ole Miss and Oklahoma for the Mobile (Ala.) St. Paul’s passer.
Eddie Lacy, RB (2009) AC100
The burly runner from Geismar (La.) Dutchtown was the No. 5-rated player in The Pelican State. Lacy was the No. 93-rated overall player in the AC100 and was the No. 11-rated running back behind names like Trent Richardson, Cierre Wood, Lamar Miller and Christine Michael. He picked Alabama over Oklahoma, Ole Miss, Tennessee and Mississippi State. Interestingly enough, LSU didn’t offer the in-state prospect. He was a four-star prospect by Rivals.com.
Christian Jones, WR (2011) National Recruit
A safety prospect from Adamsville (Ala.) Minor High School, Jones was a four-star prospect by rivals. He was the No. 18-rated safety in the nation and the No. 8-rated player in the state — a year in which Auburn signed four of the top six players in the state. Jones picked Bama over other elite offers like Auburn, Florida, Notre Dame, Tennessee, Texas A&M and UCLA.
Kevin Norwood, WR (2009) National Recruit
The D’Iberville (Miss.) High prospect had four offers coming out of high school. Alabama, Ole Miss, Mississippi State and Southern Miss were Norwood’s finalists. Rivals ranked the wideout a four-star player as the No. 147-rated player in the nation regardless of position. He was listed as the No. 5 player in The Magnolia State and the No. 22 wide receiver in the nation.
Amari Cooper, WR (2012) AC100
The big-play four-star freshman was an elite recruit who every school wanted. Alabama beat-out Miami, Florida, Florida State, West Virginia and dozens more for the Miami (Fla.) Northwestern prospect. Cooper was the No. 10-rated player in the state, the No. 8-rated wide receiver in the nation and was the No. 58-rated overall prospect in the nation (AC100). He isn’t the Freshman of the Year, but no first-year player will impact the national title more than this young pass-catcher. That includes T.J. Yeldon.
Chance Warmack, OG (2009)
This big blocker from Atlanta (Ga.) Westlake picked Alabama over Auburn, South Carolina and Rutgers. Warmack was ranked as the No. 29 player in the state of Georgia and the No. 20 offensive guard in the nation by Rivals.com. He was a three-star recruit.
Barrett Jones, C (2008) National Recruit
This Memphis (Tenn.) Evangelical Christian stud was the No. 1 prospect in the state of Tennessee (which included Dont’a Hightower), the No. 17 offensive lineman in the nation and the No. 146-rated player nationally regardless of position. He possessed offers from nearly everyone in the southeast but visited only Alabama, Florida and North Carolina. Jones helped Nick Saban sign the nation’s No. 1 class in 2008.
D.J. Fluker, OT (2009) AC100
This monster of a recruit actually moved from Biloxi, Miss., to Foley, Ala., for his final season of prep play. And everybody wanted him. He was the No. 2-rated offensive lineman in the nation and was ranked No. 19 overall in the 2009 AC100. He was the No. 10-rated player to enter the SEC and was second only to Dre Kirkpatrick in the Bama recruiting rankings. Fluker, who was committed to Alabama for over a year, was listed as big as 6-foot-7 as a recruit and upwards of 350 pounds by Rivals.com (he was listed officially at a modest 6-foot-5, 340 as an incoming freshman). He was a five-star talent.
Cyrus Kouandjio, OL (2011) AC100
The massive sophomore trailed only South Carolina’s Jadeveon Clowney in the 2011 Athlon Consensus 100 rankings. He was the No. 2-rated player in the nation and obviously was the No. 1-rated offensive lineman in the nation. The Hyattsville (Md.) DeMatha followed his older brother from Maryland (as the No. 1 player in the state) South to Tuscaloosa. The younger Kouandjio actually announced on National Signing Day that he was headed to Auburn only to sign papers with Alabama later that day.
Anthony Steen, OL (2009)
The guard from Clarksdale (Miss.) Lee Academy was a three-star prospect back in 2009. He was the No. 26-rated offensive guard in the nation and the No. 16-rated player in the state. Even Nick Saban’s three-star signees are highly-touted as Steen also had offers from Florida State, Miami and Southern Miss.
Michael Williams, TE (2008) National Recruit
Williams was an all-state talent and the 2A Lineman of the Year from Reform (Ala.) Pickens County. Williams was a highly touted prospect who picked Alabama over Clemson and Georgia Tech — he just wasn’t a tight end. Williams was evaluated as the No. 17 defensive end in the nation by Scout and the No. 4 weakside defensive end in the nation by Rivals after 24 sacks over his final two prep seasons. His blocking and pass-catching skills proved to be too much, however, as he will start at tight end in the national championship game.
Honorable Mention: T.J. Yeldon, RB (2012) AC100
The future superstar (if he's not already) is more of a co-starter than a back-up. The Daphne (Ala.) High prospect was an AC100 talent who ranked as the No. 32 overall prospect in the nation by Athlon Sports. He was the No. 3-rated player in the state (behind Jameis Winston and Chris Casher) and the No. 4-rated running back in the nation (behind Johnathan Gray, Keith Marshall and Trey Williams). Any coach in the nation would have taken Yeldon as Rivals gave him the rare fifth star.
Star ranking breakdown of Alabama's starting line-up (by Rivals.com, not counting Yeldon):
No. of Players
2012 Alabama's Starting Defense as Recruits
Jesse Williams, DE (2011) JUCO
Williams came a long way to get to the Capstone and the BCS National Championship game. Originally from Cavendish Road High School in Brisbane, Australia, Williams enrolled at Western Arizona Community College in Yuma, Arizona in 2009. After two seasons as a JUCO, Williams signed with Alabama in the spring of 2011 as the No. 2-rated junior college prospect in the nation and a four-star player. The 6-foot-4, 330-pounder obviously made a big impact in only one year on campus.
Damion Square, DL (2008)
One of the unsung heroes of the Alabama team is one of the elder statesman. A 2008 three-star prospect from Houston (Texas) Yates, Square was the No. 55-rated player in the state of Texas and was the No. 37-rated defensive tackle in the nation by Rivals. He signed with the Crimson Tide over offers from Michigan, Nebraska, Texas A&M, Oklahoma State and Tennessee.
Ed Stinson, DL (2009) National Recruit
Rivals rated the Homestead (Fla.) South Dade prospect as a four-star weakside defensive end. He was ranked the No. 48 player in The Sunshine State and the No. 15-best weakside defensive end in the nation. He had offers from Auburn, Florida State, LSU and Miami along with the Crimson Tide.
C.J. Mosley, LB (2010) National Recruit
Much like Joeckel, Mosley just missed landing in the AC100 as a linebacker from Theodore (Ala.) High. He was the No. 113-rated overall prospect in the nation. Mosley finished as the No. 9-rated linebacker in the nation and the No. 3-rated player in the state of Alabama. Every program in the Southeast as well as a few from the Big 12 (Oklahoma) and the West Coast (Stanford) wanted to ink the star tackler.
Trey DePriest, LB (2011) AC100
The only player ranked ahead of the Springfield (Ohio) High prospect in the state was Ohio State star quarterback Braxton Miller. The linebacker was the No. 32-rated overall player in the Athlon Consensus 100 and was the No. 6-rated linebacker in the nation by Athlon Sports. Rivals gave him four-stars and DePriest had his pick of any school in the nation. Alabama defeated elite programs from coast-to-coast (Ohio State, LSU, Stanford, Florida, Notre Dame, Virginia Tech to name a few) to land the steady player.
Nico Johnson, LB (2009) AC100
A five-star prospect by Rivals, the Andalusia (Ala.) High outside linebacker was highly coveted by every Southeastern power. LSU, Auburn and Alabama were his eventual finalists and he ended the ’09 recruiting cycle as the No. 21-rated player in the nation by the AC100. He trailed only Dre Kirkpatrick and D.J. Fluker inside The Yellowhammer State rankings and was the No. 5-rated linebacker in the nation behind only Manti Te’o, Vontaze Burfict, Jelani Jenkins and Dorian Bell.
Adrian Hubbard, LB (2010) National Recruit
The Norcross (Ga.) High prospect barely missed landing in the AC100 as the No. 145-rated player in the country in the Class of 2010. Athlon Sports ranked him the No. 12-best linebacker prospect in the nation behind names like Jordan Hicks, Alec Ogletree, Corey Nelson, CJ Mosley and Christian Jones. The 6-foot-6, 220-pound prospect picked the Tide over Auburn, Clemson, Florida State, Georgia and South Carolina (among others). He was a four-star recruit by Rivals.
Dee Milliner, CB (2010) AC100
Only two players were ranked ahead of Mosley in the state of Alabama in 2010 and Milliner was one of them. The Millbrook (Ala.) Stanhope Elmore cornerback was the No. 1-rated player in the state and the No. 3-rated defensive back in the nation. He finished as the No. 15-rated overall prospect in the nation by Athlon Sports. His offers sheet included every major program from the Southeast.
Deion Belue, CB (2012) JUCO
Originally from Tuscumbia (Ala.) Deshler, Belue committed to Alabama over Auburn, Southern Miss and UAB back in 2010. The three-star instead landed in junior college at Booneville (Miss.) Northeast Mississippi C.C. Two years later, Belue finally got to Tuscaloosa after signing with Alabama for the second time as a three-star prospect (Rivals).
Ha-Ha Clinton-Dix, S (2011) AC100
Few players were more highly-touted in the deep Alabama class of 2011 than Clinton-Dix. In a group that included DePreist, Xzavier Dickson and more, only Kouandjio ranked higher than the Orlando (Fla.) Dr. Phillips product. He was the No. 10-rated player in the nation by the Athlon Consensus 100 and was given the prestigious fifth star by Rivals. Athlon ranked him the No. 1 player in the state of Florida and the No. 1 defensive back in the nation. USC, Florida, Florida State, Ohio State, South Carolina and Notre Dame are just a few programs Saban beat for the signature of HaSean “Ha-Ha” Clinton-Dix.
Robert Lester, S (2008) National Recruit
The Foley (Ala.) native was ranked as the No. 23 safety in the nation by Rivals back in 2008. His two finalists were Oklahoma and Alabama. The four-star prospect was ranked as the No. 15 player in the state of Alabama and has 10 interceptions over the last two seasons.
Athlon Consensus 100: The Top 100 Recruits in the Nation
The 2012 All-America Team as Recruits
The 2012 All-Big 12 Team as Recruits
The 2012 All-Pac-12 Team as Recruits
The 2012 All-ACC Team as Recruits
The 2012 All-Big Ten Team as Recruits
The 2012 All-SEC Team as Recruits
The 2012 All-Big East Team as Recruits