Publish date:

Jameis Winston vs. Marcus Mariota in the Rose Bowl is a QB Matchup for the Ages

Author:
Quarterbacks.png

LOS ANGELES — Jameis Winston is right.

The Florida State quarterback is saying all the right things about his matchup with Oregon quarterback Marcus Mariota.

The game will feature the last two Heisman winners on opposite sidelines, only the third time Heisman winners have faced each other in a bowl game.

As expected, neither Winston nor Mariota are talking it up as the superstar showdown the rest of us know it is.

“I'm not facing him; I'm facing his defense,” Winston said. “It's going to be a Florida State team versus Oregon team not Jameis Winston versus Marcus Mariota.”

Let’s entertain that notion a bit more seriously and not as a cliche.

Winston and Mariota will be facing two defenses led by coordinators who were position coaches this time last year.

That’s the reason we should be excited. Not simply because Winston and Mariota will put two Heisman winners on the field for the first time since 2009.

The Rose Bowl will be a national semifinal matching up two Heisman winners against two first-year coordinators. Neither defense is ranked in the top 50 nationally in yards per game. Oregon is down a star cornerback. Florida State is a shadow of the defense that ranked third nationally last season.

In other words, all the conditions are ripe for Mariota and Winston to put on a show, the nation's most efficent quarterback against the nation's most clutch. 

Recommended Articles

Fans should be grateful. Where the Sugar Bowl semifinal seems to be a game driven by coaches and conferences, the Rose Bowl will be driven by quarterbacks.

One has never lost a collegiate game. One has thrown two interceptions all year and four last year, ludicrous numbers for 2015.

For a few hours on New Year's Day, both programs hope to strip away some of the narratives about the two. The arguments about these two quarterbacks are either lazy (the narrative of Mariota’s squeaky clean image vs. Winston’s troublesome off-field track record) or soon will become tiresome by the NFL Combine (should Winston fall in the draft? Is Mariota a system quarterback?).

In some ways, even the coaches are just sending in a play and watching what happens.

“I've quit questioning what he does on the field and why he does it,” Florida State coach Jimbo Fisher said. “Even when he does it wrong, he can come off and tell you exactly what he saw, what happened, and why it happened. I'll bet it's (right) a 98 percent rate, when he comes off, he can process so much information. His intelligence level is off the charts.”

The future, beyond Jan. 1 and potentially a national championship game, isn’t a topic either are ready to entertain.

Will Mariota and Winston be great NFL quarterbacks? Maybe. Maybe not. Is Mariota too nice? Is he the dreaded system quarterback who will struggle to translate his game to the pro level?

Oregon coach Mark Helfrich is resigned, for now, to say that it will either happen or it won’t.

“I know with both the quarterbacks in this game, they can play at any level,” Helfrich said. “Both those guys, they're completely different, totally different guys from a style standpoint, but both will have tremendous NFL careers if they end up in the right spot. If they don't, things can go different ways.”

In the present, it’s going to be a good show, one that even Winston is going to try to stop and enjoy.

“I think it's going to be a once‑in‑a‑lifetime opportunity to see us play and me personally I'm going to be on the sideline watching Marcus myself,” he said. “I think it's going to be a fun game.”