Skip to main content

Ranking the Big 12's College Football Coaches


by Steven Lassan (@AthlonSteven on twitter) and Braden Gall (@BradenGall)

Ranking the coaches in any college football conference is a difficult task. Many factors play into just how successful a coach is at any school. How well are the assistants paid? Are the facilities up to par with the rest of the conference? Can the coach recruit or is he more of an x's and o's manager? Are there off-the-field or age issues to take into consideration? Has a coach built a program or continued the success from a previous coach? How is the resume outside of their current position? These questions and more were posed to the editors at Athlon Sports, as they were asked to rank the coaches of each of the six BCS conferences. One thing to keep in mind - the record is not always indicative of where a coach should rank in a conference. 

Ranking the Coaches:ACC
Ranking the Coaches:Big East
Ranking the Coaches:Pac-12
Ranking the Coaches:Big 12
Ranking the Coaches: Big Ten (Wed.)
Ranking the Coaches: SEC (Thur.)
Ranking the Coaches: 2012 Top 25 Coaches (Fri.)

Here is how Athlon Sports ranks the coaches of the Big 12:

1. Bob Stoops, Oklahoma (13 years)
Alma Mater:
Iowa (1979-82)
Record: 139-34 (1999-present)

The Sooners have had a few down years under Stoops, but since his arrival in Norman, Oklahoma has emerged once again as a national power. Stoops’ tenure has been a picture of success, leading the Sooners to 10 double-digit win seasons and eight BCS bowl appearances. The biggest knock on Stoops has been the lack of success in BCS bowl games, as Oklahoma is just 1-5 in its last six BCS bowl appearances. And that criticism of Stoops always stirs this debate: Would you take a coach that struggles to get to a BCS bowl and wins one every eight years or take a coach that consistently gets there, but has a disappointing BCS record after six years? Regardless of whether or not Stoops wins three BCS bowls in a row or loses the next three, it’s going to be hard to knock him off the top spot in the Big 12.

Image placeholder title

What Coaches By the Numbers Has to Say:

·       Bob Stoops has more wins (119) from 2001-Present than any other active head coach

·       Bob Stoops is 66-3 in home games 

·       Bob Stoops is 96-5 when scoring 30 or more points in a game

·       Bob Stoops teams have scored 30 or more points 101 times (68.24%)

·       Bob Stoops is 63-25 (71.59%) vs. teams finishing the season over .500

2. Gary Patterson, TCU (12 years)
Alma Mater: Kansas State
Record: 109-30 (2000-present)

Patterson coached at 10 different programs over a 16-year period before given the chance to lead TCU in 2000 (one game). The hard-nosed defensive guru went to bowl games in three straight seasons to start his career and needed only two years to register his first 10-win season. It was only the second 10-win season for the Horned Frogs in the Post-World War II era. He has rattled off eight such seasons over the last 10 years in Fort Worth, including a current streak of four straight. He has won the program’s first BCS Bowl (Rose in 2010) and has elevated TCU to a BCS level as the Frogs will join the Big 12 in 2012. In 11 full seasons on the job, Patterson has five conference championships, three conference Coach of the Year awards and was the unanimous 2009 National Coach of the Year (AFCA, AP, Walter Camp, Boddy Dodd, Eddie Robinson, Liberty Mutual). TCU has experienced one losing season under Patterson (2004), but has been to a bowl every year since, winning seven of those eight post-season games. TCU has gone 36-3 over the last three years with 13 NFL Draft picks over that span and two BCS bowl appearances.

Image placeholder title

What Coaches By the Numbers Has to Say:

·       Patterson is 45-21 (68.18%) vs. teams finishing the season over .500

·       Patterson is 7-3 in bowl games

·       Patterson has won 10+ games 8 times from 2001-Present

·       Patterson's defenses force a 3-and-out or a turnover in 50.72% of possessions

·       Patterson's defenses have given up 20 points or less in 60% of the games he has been the head coach

3. Mike Gundy, Oklahoma State (7 years)
Alma Mater: Oklahoma State (1986-89)
Record: 59-30 (2005-present)

Gundy has been slowly moving up the Big 12 coach rankings over the last few seasons. After posting 18 victories through his first three seasons in Stillwater, Gundy has led the Cowboys to four consecutive years of at least nine wins. Oklahoma State is coming off its first BCS bowl appearances and was one win away from playing for the national championship. The Big 12 isn’t getting any easier with the arrival of West Virginia and TCU, but Gundy has the Cowboys well-positioned to remain a conference title contender for the foreseeable future.

Image placeholder title

What Coaches By the Numbers Has to Say:

·       Gundy's teams have scored TD's in 38.14% of offensive possessions

·       Gundy's teams have scored 40+ pts in 40.45% of the games he has been the head coach

·       Gundy is 1-6 vs. Oklahoma

·       Gundy has won 9+ games every year from 2008-2011

4. Mack Brown, Texas (14 years)
Alma Mater:
Vanderbilt, Florida State
Record: 141-39 (1998-present)
Record: 69-46-1 (North Carolina, 1988-97)
Record: 11-23 (Tulane, 1985-87)
Record: 6-5 (Appalachian St, 1983)
Overall: 227-113-1

Senator Brown has seen better days but still must be considered one of the league’s best options. After learning the coaching ropes at FCS power Appalachian State and Tulane, Brown rebuilt the North Carolina program. He posted three 10-win seasons in Chapel Hill and went to six straight bowls before taking the best job in college football. All Brown did in his first 13 seasons on the 40 Acres was win at least nine games and finish no worse than second in the South Division every year. After seven seasons, including three Big 12 South titles, Brown broke through with his first conference title in 2005. Behind the leadership of Vince Young, Texas won one of college football's greatest games ever played against USC in the Rose Bowl and the National Championship returned to Austin for the first time since 1970. Despite another trip to the national title game in 2009, Brown’s program eroded in 2010. He posted his first losing season since 1989 as a head coach and was forced to fire multiple assistants. The Horns returned to their winning ways last fall and 2012 will go a long way in proving whether or not Brown has gotten complacent or should be ranked No. 1 on this list. Texas is the single best coaching job in America with more natural and financial resources than any other program in the nation. Therefore, recruiting and on-the-field success should be measured with more scrutiny — especially for a man who has, for some reason, dealt with retirement rumors of late.

Image placeholder title

What Coaches By the Numbers Has to Say:

·       Mack Brown is 56-25 (70.24%) vs. teams finishing the season over .500

·       Mack Brown is 23-4 (85.19%) in games decided by 4 pts or less

·       Texas won 60.34% of their games in the five years prior to Brown's arrival. Brown has won 80.28%

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

·       Brown has had 12 first round draft picks from 2001-2011

5. Bill Snyder, Kansas State (20 years)
Alma Mater: William Jewell (1959-1962)
Record: 159-83-1 (1989-2005), (2009-present)

Prior to Snyder’s arrival in Manhattan, the Wildcats had struggled to find much success on the gridiron. From 1985-88, Kansas State posted an awful 3-40 record and had only one winning season from 1971-82. Snyder won only one game in his first season, but recorded at least five in every season from 1990-2003. Under his watch, the Wildcats have made two BCS bowl appearances and won or shared the Big 12 title four times. The one concern about Snyder is his age. Although he shows no signs of slowing down, he will be 73 at the end of the 2012 season. If you are an athletic director looking to make a hire and Snyder is one of three available candidates – you have to wonder how many years he will stick around. However, Snyder understands the culture and what it takes to win at Kansas State. It’s not an easy job, but Snyder has transformed the Wildcats from a laughingstock to a consistent contender in the Big 12.

Image placeholder title

What Coaches By the Numbers Has to Say:

·       Five years prior to Snyder being named the head coach, Kansas St. won 10.77% of their games. Snyder has won 60% and won 9+ games 11 times in his 20-year stint as head coach of the Wildcats

·       Snyder is 7-1 vs. Kansas

·       Since 2001, Snyder is 6-15 vs. Top 25 teams (Time of Game Ranking)

·       Since 2001, Snyder is 24-36 against teams finishing the season over .500

6. Art Briles, Baylor (4 years)
Alma Mater:
Houston, Texas Tech, Abilene Christian
Record: 25-25 (2008-present)
Record: 34-28 (Houston, 2003-2007)
Overall: 59-53

After a very long and very distinguished Texas high school coaching career from 1979 to 1999, Briles got his break at his alma mater. At Houston, Briles designed one of the most prolific passing attacks in NCAA history. Under the two previous regimes, (Kim Helton and Dana Dimel) the Cougars won an average of 3.2 games per year from 1993 to 2002 for an overall record of 32-79. Briles won more games (34) in his five-year stint at Houston as well as one conference title in 2006. He landed at Baylor after two straight C-USA West division titles and was charged with leading a dormant program into the new Big 12 era. After back-to-back 4-8 seasons, Briles (with a little help from Robert Griffin III) led the Bears to its first bowl game since 1994. Over the last two seaons, Baylor won its first postseason contest since 1992 and more games (17) over a two-year span than it has since 1985-1986 (18). Griffin III claimed the first Heisman Trophy in school history and will likely be the second pick in the 2012 NFL Draft. Can Briles maintain the Bears’ current level of success without the most valuable player in the nation and most popular player in school history? This is what Briles is charged with in 2012.

Image placeholder title

What Coaches By the Numbers Has to Say:

·       Baylor won 31.13% of their games 5 yrs prior to Briles' arrival. Briles has won 50% 

·       Briles is 16-49 vs. teams finishing the season over .500

·       Art Briles teams go 3-and-out on offense just 18.23% of the time

·       Art Briles is 4-20 vs. Top 25 teams (Time of Game ranking)

7. Paul Rhoads, Iowa State (3 years)
Alma Mater:
Missouri Western (1985-88)
Record: 18-20 (2009-present)

Winning at Iowa State is not easy. Auburn coach Gene Chizik posted a 5-19 record in two seasons in Ames, while Dan McCarney recorded a 56-85 mark from 1995-06. Even Johnny Majors had a so-so tenure at Iowa State, finishing with a 24-30-1 record from 1968-72. Although sustained success has been difficult to achieve, the Cyclones have some momentum after three solid years with Rhoads at the helm. The Iowa native has led the Cyclones to two bowl appearances and an 18-20 record. Although a losing record may not stand out nationally, considering how difficult it is to win at Iowa State – especially in a revamped 10-team Big 12 – Rhoads has emerged as one of the most underrated coaches in college football. Considering the head coaches in the Big 12, it’s not an easy conference to rank. Although Rhoads checks in near the middle of the rankings, one could argue (outside of Kansas State’s Bill Snyder) he has done the most with the least.  

Image placeholder title

What Coaches By the Numbers Has to Say:

·       Rhoads has lost 6 or more games in each of his 3 seasons at ISU

·       Rhoads is 3-12 vs top 25 teams (Time of Game ranking)

8. Dana Holgorsen, West Virginia (1 year)
Alma Mater:
Iowa Wesleyan (1991-92)
Record: 10-3 (2011-present)

Holgorsen was supposed to spend 2011 serving as the offensive coordinator and head-coach-in-waiting for West Virginia. However, Bill Stewart was forced to resign in early June, forcing Holgorsen to step into the head coach role a year early than expected. Even though the coaching change occurred after spring practice, it didn’t have any impact on the team. West Virginia finished 9-3 in the regular season and won the Orange Bowl in impressive fashion over Clemson. Holgorsen is one of college football’s top offensive minds, but is still learning the ropes as a head coach. West Virginia’s move to the Big 12 is a good one for Holgorsen, as he has served as the offensive coordinator at Oklahoma State and Texas Tech. Although Holgorsen is a bright offensive mind, it’s hard to rank him any higher in the Big 12 coaching ranks after just one season in Morgantown.

Image placeholder title

What Coaches By the Numbers Has to Say:

·       As an offensive coordinator and head coach, Dana Holgorsen's teams have scored 40+ points 51% of the time

9. Tommy Tuberville, Texas Tech (2 years)
Alma Mater:
Southern Arkansas
Record: 13-12 (2010-present)
Record: 85-40 (Auburn, 1999-2008)
Record: 25-20 (Ole Miss, 1995-1998)
Overall: 123-72

Tuberville has perhaps one of the most intriguing coaching careers in the nation. He took a sanction-laden Ole Miss program back to the postseason, earning SEC Coach of the Year honors in 1997. When the opportunity presented itself after his fourth season, Tubes bolted for division rival Auburn. Tuberville went on to win the SEC West five times in six years, appeared in eight straight bowls and finished the 2004 season unbeaten — the only undefeated BCS team not to win a national championship. Auburn finished lower than second in the West one time in eight years (third in 2003) and after one bad season in 2008, Tuberville supposedly “resigned voluntarily.” He surfaced at Texas Tech with an outstanding track record and positive momentum after one year as a TV analyst. Tech won eight games and a bowl in his first year, but 2011 has cast a dark shadow over Tuberville’s reputation for a variety of reasons. Aside from posting the first losing season in Lubbock since 1992, the Red Raiders allowed 51.2 points per game over the final five game (losing all of them) after pulling what was arguably the biggest upset of the year over Oklahoma. To top it all off, the ‘radioactivity’ emanating from the Tuberville household makes him a tough sell to any AD. He is mentioned in a potential lawsuit back in Alabama involving alleged investment transgressions, and his wife has her own legal troubles following a car accident in late 2011. Just three years ago, Tuberville would have been near the top of this list. And his fall from coaching grace is as sensational as it was rapid.

Image placeholder title

What Coaches By the Numbers Has to Say:

·       At Texas Tech, Tuberville's teams have given up 30+ pts 64% of the time

·       At Texas Tech, Tuberville's teams have given up 40+ pts 36% of the time

10. Charlie Weis, Kansas (First year)
Alma Mater:
Notre Dame
Record: 35-27 (Notre Dame, 2005-2009)

Gastric bypass surgery aside, Weis has had a lumpy head-coaching career. He took Ty Willingham’s players and went to back-to-back BCS bowl games where his Irish got shellacked by Ohio State and LSU. Since the loss to the Bayou Bengals, Weis went 16-21 as the head coach before getting aced by Notre Dame. He has shown he is a successful NFL offensive architect (NY Jets, New England, Kansas City), but has much to prove if he plans on keeping ‘Head Coach’ in front of his name on the college level. His Florida offense struggled mightily a season ago, but how much of that was spread players not fitting his pro-style scheme? For now, Weis seems to be closer to Norv Turner than Bill Belichick.

Image placeholder title

Related Content Links:

College Football's Top Transfers to Watch for 2012
College Football's Top Spring QB Battles to Watch

Top Transfers to Watch in 2012
Early Top 25 for 2012
College Football's Top Spring Storylines for 2012
College Football's Coaches on the Hot Seat