Florida State is starting over at quarterback next season after 2013 Heisman winner Jameis Winston declared for the NFL Draft on Wednesday. Replacing Winston’s on-field production will be one of college football’s top offseason storylines to monitor, as coach Jimbo Fisher has a cast of talented, yet largely unproven options in the mix.
Before previewing Florida State’s quarterback battle for 2015, let’s take a step back and examine Winston’s two-year career in Tallahassee.
Winston’s departure ends one of the top two-year runs by a quarterback in recent memory. The Seminoles went 26-1 under Winston and claimed the 2013 national championship with a victory over Auburn last season. The Alabama native led Florida State to the playoff in 2014, but the Seminoles lost 59-20 to Oregon in the Rose Bowl.
Statistically, Winston’s numbers dropped from 2013 to 2014. After throwing for 4,057 yards and 40 touchdowns in 2013, Winston threw for 3,907 yards and 25 scores in 2014. Additionally, Winston’s interceptions climbed from 10 (2013) to 18 this year.
Even with Winston’s drop in production, coach Jimbo Fisher believed the sophomore had a better year than he did in 2013. It’s also worth noting Winston was playing with a revamped receiving corps and a shuffled offensive line that struggled at times in 2014.
While Winston received plenty of attention for off-field matters, his two-year run at Florida State is going to be hard to top by the next starter or any passer in Tallahassee. And it’s not unfathomable to suggest Winston was the most talented quarterback to play at Florida State.
Considering Winston’s two-year run in Tallahassee, there are big shoes to fill under center. Assuming Winston goes in the first few picks as expected, he will become the third consecutive Florida State quarterback to go in the first round of the NFL Draft. That’s some impressive accolades for Fisher to tout on the recruiting trail.
Let’s examine the next options in Tallahassee:
2015 Year of Eligibility: Junior
Maguire should open spring practice as the favorite to win the quarterback job. The New Jersey native was a three-star recruit coming out of high school after running a wing-T offense at Seton Hall Prep. In two years of snaps at Florida State, Maguire completed 38 of 70 passes for 455 yards, three scores and four interceptions. He has one start (Clemson) under his belt, throwing for 304 yards against a tough defense on Sept. 20 this year. Maguire isn’t as talented as Winston, but he has experience in the offense.
2015 Year of Eligibility: Redshirt Freshman
Cosentino is a Pennsylvania native with plenty of talent, but he’s also a bit on the raw side after also playing in a wing-T offense in high school. Cosentino was considered by 247Sports to be a four-star recruit last year and redshirted in his first year on campus. The talent is certainly there for Cosentino. How quickly can he adapt to Fisher’s offense?
John Franklin III
2015 Year of Eligibility: Sophomore
Franklin III played in two games this year after spending 2013 as a redshirt. The Florida native isn’t short on athleticism, as he was a member of Florida State’s track and field teams. According to his school bio, Franklin III recorded a 6.82 time in the 60-meter dash and shared Offensive Scout Team Player Award honors with Wilson Bell last year. Franklin III is probably a longshot to win the starting job next year.
The wild card: Braxton Miller
Ohio State’s quarterback situation is crowded for 2015. Cardale Jones, J.T. Barrett and Braxton Miller are each proven options for coach Urban Meyer. Miller is eligible to transfer and start at another program in 2015, and unless he’s guaranteed a starting spot in Columbus, it’s hard to envision the senior staying to sit on the bench or playing sparingly as a third-string quarterback. The Palm Beach Post reported in late December there was interest from Miller about transferring to Florida State. Miller is a different quarterback than what Fisher has worked with recently, as the senior is a dynamic dual-threat option. However, Miller is coming off two shoulder surgeries and may not be at full strength by this spring. Although Miller has the talent to be an All-American quarterback, he seems like an unlikely fit for Florida State.
Florida State has three freshman quarterbacks committed (as of Jan. 7).
4-Star by 247Sports Composite, No. 100 recruit nationally
Kai Locksley (listed by 247 as an athlete)
4-Star by 247Sports Composite, No. 225 recruit nationally
3-Star by 247Sports Composite, No. 377 recruit nationally
Johnson is already enrolled at Florida State, but Francois and Locksley could still flip to another school by Signing Day. Even if all three sign with the Seminoles, it’s hard to envision a true freshman taking the first snap of the year for Fisher.
The Supporting Cast Consideration
Regardless of which quarterback starts for Florida State next season, Fisher and the staff needs to retool the supporting cast. Receiver Rashad Greene and tight end Nick O’Leary combined to catch 147 of the Seminoles’ 330 completions in 2014, and both players have expired their eligibility. There’s certainly no shortage of talent, as Travis Rudolph, Ermon Lane, Jesus Wilson and Isaiah Jones is a solid group of young receivers. Four starters must be replaced on the offensive line, but left tackle Roderick Johnson is a good place to start the rebuilding effort. And the new quarterback will have a rising star in sophomore Dalvin Cook to lean on at running back.
Maguire takes the first snap of 2015 for Florida State. Even though he wasn’t the biggest recruit in the quarterback huddle for the Seminoles, the New Jersey native has experience and will have a better grasp of the offense with an offseason to work as the No. 1 passer. Maguire’s first start (Clemson) wasn’t overly impressive on the stat sheet (21 of 39, 304 yards, two picks), but it’s also important to consider the Tigers had one of the best defenses in college football in 2014. Fisher will find an answer at quarterback by the opener, and the guess here is Maguire is the starter against Texas State.