A Traveler's Ranking of the Bowls Outside the New Year’s Six

The name may change, but it's the history and atmosphere that always makes the Citrus Bowl a top destination

Every college football fan wants his or her team to end up in one of the “New Year’s Six” bowl games. When that happens, folks disrupt their holiday plans and make the trek to Atlanta, Dallas, Miami, New Orleans, Pasadena or Phoenix.

 

However, only 12 teams make that cut each season and there are 33 other bowl games that need to put butts in the seats. Some of these games are worth adjusting holiday plans to go see, while others are not. There are numerous rankings of the bowls this year based on their slated matchups, but choosing to watch a game on television and actually traveling to it comes with a few more factors, including location, the game’s history and its continued ability to produce quality matchups. Here is a ranking of the bowl games based on those factors.

 

Bowl Watchability Rankings by Power Five Conference: ACC I Big 12 I Big Ten I Pac-12 I SEC

 

33. DXL Frisco Bowl

Location: Toyota Stadium – Frisco, Texas

Launched: 2014

This Year’s Matchup: Louisiana Tech vs. SMU (Dec. 20, 2017)

After the Miami Beach Bowl was acquired by ESPN, it was moved to Frisco, a suburb of Dallas, and rebranded as the DXL Frisco Bowl. Only time will tell if that move was a success.

 

32. Bad Boy Mowers Gasparilla Bowl

Location: Tropicana Field – St. Petersburg, Fla.

Launched: 2008

This Year’s Game: Temple vs. Florida International (Dec. 21, 2017)

The game originally dubbed the magicJack St. Petersburg Bowl got a new name this year thanks to a sponsorship by Bad Boy Mowers and a nod to Tampa’s Gasparilla Pirate Festival. Now it sounds like a bowl game in a satire about college football.

 

31. Raycom Media Camellia Bowl

Location: Cramton Bowl – Montgomery, Ala.

Launched: 2014

This Year’s Game: Middle Tennessee vs. Arkansas State (Dec. 16, 2017)

If you’re a sports history buff, a trip to Montgomery to watch a game in in the historic Cramton Bowl may be right up your alley. But for many, that’s a big if.

 

30. Famous Idaho Potato Bowl

Location: Albertsons Stadium – Boise, Idaho

Launched: 1997

This Year’s Game: Central Michigan vs. Wyoming (Dec. 22, 2017)

This bowl has had a history of good matchups, but is ranked this low because flying to Boise generally requires a connection and fans then have to watch a game outside in Idaho in December. 

 

29. Quick Lane Bowl

Location: Ford Field – Detroit

Launched: 2014

This Year’s Game: Duke vs. Northern Illinois (Dec. 26, 2017)

At least this game is played indoors, but you still have to go to Detroit… in December.

 

28. Hawaii Bowl

Location: Aloha Stadium – Honolulu

Launched: 2002

This Year’s Matchup: Fresno State vs. Houston (Dec. 24, 2017)

This year’s matchup should make for a great game, but I imagine the majority of the Fresno State and Houston fan bases will be watching the game on television since it will be played in Hawaii… on Christmas Eve.

 

27. NOVA Loans Arizona Bowl

Location: Arizona Stadium – Tucson, Ariz.

Launched: 2015

This Year’s Game: New Mexico State vs. Utah State (Dec. 29, 2017)

Watching two 6-6 teams fighting to get above .500 may not be worth a trip to the desert. However, if Aggie fans on both sides choose to go, they should hit El Charro, the Titan Missile Museum, and the Arizona-Sonora Desert Museum to make the trip worthwhile.

 

26. AutoNation Cure Bowl

Location: Camping World Stadium – Orlando, Fla.

Launched: 2015

This Year’s Game: Western Kentucky vs. Georgia State (Dec. 16, 2017)

The quality of this game is mediocre at best, but its proceeds go to the Breast Cancer Research Foundation and it is played at a time where fans can travel to it without disrupting their holiday plans.

 

25. Bahamas Bowl

Location: Thomas Robinson Bowl – Nassau, Bahamas

Launched: 2014

This Year’s Game: UAB vs. Ohio (Dec. 22, 2017)

The only bowl game played outside the U.S. hosts second-tier MAC and Conference USA teams. While it is always fun to visit the Bahamas, it may not be worth the money and disrupted holiday plans to watch your non-Power 5 team that did not win its conference.

 

24. Dollar General Bowl

Location: Ladd Peebles Stadium – Mobile, Ala.

Launched: 1999

This Year’s Game: Appalachian State vs. Toledo (Dec. 23, 2017)

This game was originally sponsored by GMAC, then GoDaddy.com before Dollar General took over this year’s contest. It pits quality MAC and Sun Belt schools against each other and there are worse places to go this time of year than Mobile.

 

23. Birmingham Bowl

Location: Legion Field – Birmingham, Ala.

Launched: 2006

This Year’s Game: Texas Tech vs. South Florida (Dec. 23, 2017)

The Birmingham Bowl matches one of the best teams in the AAC against one of the Power 5’s (usually the SEC’s) worst bowl-eligible teams. For fans of the AAC school, it is a chance to see if their team can hang with the big boys in one of the South’s most storied stadiums.

 

22. Gildan New Mexico Bowl

Location: Dreamstyle Stadium – Albuquerque, N.M.

Launched: 2006

This Year’s Game: Marshall vs. Colorado State (Dec. 16, 2017)

The New Mexico Bowl has tie-ins with the Mountain West and Conference USA, two conferences that normally do not play each other. This year, Marshall and Colorado State will meet for the first time.

 

21. Military Bowl Presented by Northrop Grumman

Location: Navy-Marine Corps Memorial Stadium – Annapolis, Md.

Launched: 2008

This Year’s Game: Virginia vs. Navy (Dec. 28, 2017)

This bowl seems to have found its footing since it moved from Washington D.C.’s RFK Stadium to Annapolis and signed agreements with the ACC and AAC. Now it hosts a game in a beautiful town that is generally within driving distance for both schools a few days after Christmas. Well done.

 

20. Cheribundi Tart Cherry Boca Raton Bowl

Location: FAU Stadium – Boca Raton, Fla.

Launched: 2014

This Year’s Game: Akron vs. Florida Atlantic (Dec. 19, 2017)

This year’s bowl is essentially a home game for Florida Atlantic, but if FAU Stadium ever expands, this game may grow with it given its location.

 

19. Lockheed Martin Armed Forces Bowl

Location: Amon G. Carter Stadium – Fort Worth, Texas

Launched: 2003

This year’s Game: San Diego State vs. Army (Dec. 23, 2017)

Originally sponsored by PlainCapital Bank, Bell Helicopter took the game over in 2006 and it was renamed the Armed Forces Bowl. It has multi-year agreements with the AAC, Big Ten, Big 12, Mountain West, Army and Navy so the quality of the game really depends on the year. Either way, fans can enjoy the nightlife of Fort Worth’s Stock Yards.

 

18. Foster Farms Bowl

Location: Levi’s Stadium – Santa Clara, Calif.

Launched: 2002

This Year’s Game: Arizona vs. Purdue (Dec. 27, 2017)

This bowl game, which started as the San Francisco Bowl and later named the Kraft Fight Hunger Bowl, struggled to find its identity before Foster Farms sponsored the game in 2014 and signed agreements with the Big Ten and Pac-12. For fans, it is not quite the Rose Bowl, but there is plenty to do in San Francisco.

 

17. R+L Carriers New Orleans Bowl

Location: Mercedes-Benz Superdome – New Orleans

Launched: 2001

This Year’s Game: Troy vs. North Texas (Dec. 16, 2017)

This game is this high because its: a) played in arguably the most festive city in the country, and b) usually selects schools within driving distance to the Crescent City.

 

16. Zaxby’s Heart of Dallas Bowl

Location: Cotton Bowl – Dallas

Launched: 2011

This Year’s Game: Utah vs. West Virginia (Dec. 26, 2017)

If you want to see a bowl game played in the old Cotton Bowl stadium, this is your only chance to do so since the actual Cotton Bowl is now played at AT&T Stadium. Otherwise, this game can be hit or miss with its matchups.

 

15. Walk-On’s Independence Bowl

Location: Independence Stadium – Shreveport, La.

Launched: 1976

This Year’s Game: Southern Miss vs. Florida State (Dec. 27, 2017)

Before the bowl explosion that began in the 1990s, the Independence Bowl, which got its name because it launched the year of our nation’s Bicentennial celebration, was considered the worst bowl game because of its location. Nevertheless, Shreveport makes up for its lack of atmosphere by hosting good football. It has historical ties with the Power 5 conferences and 10 of its last 16 games have been decided by a touchdown or less.

 

14. Academy Sports + Outdoors Texas Bowl

Location: NRG Stadium – Houston

Launched: 2006

This Year’s Game: Texas vs. Missouri (Dec. 27, 2017)

All good bowls outside the New Year’s Six strive to create regional matchups against good teams. After the Texas Bowl signed agreements for the Big 12 and SEC to begin playing each other in 2014, it began accomplishing that goal. The only problem is that it’s still played in Houston.

 

13. Las Vegas Bowl Presented by Geico

Location: Sam Boyd Stadium – Whitney, Nev.

Launched: 1992

This Year’s Game: Boise State vs. Oregon (Dec. 16, 2017)

The best of the first weekend bowl games pits the top team in the Mountain West (barring a New Year’s Six bowl invite) against a Pac-12 team in Las Vegas. To quote Kramer, “Giddy up.”

 

12. Franklin American Mortgage Company Music City Bowl

Location: Nissan Stadium – Nashville, Tenn.

Launched: 1998

This Year’s Game: Kentucky vs. Northwestern (Dec. 29, 2017)

No team starts the season saying “Music City Bowl or bust,” but every game in this event’s history except two has been fairly close. Plus, Nashville is the only city where you can walk in and out of countless clubs and hear amazing music.

 

11. Camping World Bowl

Location: Camping World Stadium – Orlando, Fla.

Launched: 1990

This Year’s Game: Virginia Tech vs. Oklahoma State (Dec. 28, 2017)

Originally launched as the Blockbuster Bowl in Miami in 1990, this contest moved north to Orlando in 2001. It currently has agreements with the Big 12 and ACC, but the games of the last 28 years have been interesting matchups between good programs.

 

10. Cactus Bowl

Location: Chase Field – Phoenix

Launched: 1989

This Year’s Game: Kansas State vs. UCLA (Dec. 26, 2017)

Pardon the déjà vu, but this game started as the Copper Bowl in Tucson in 1989 and then moved north to the Phoenix Metropolitan area in 2000. This year, it will again be played at Chase Field while Sun Devil Stadium undergoes renovations.

 

9. AutoZone Liberty Bowl

Location: Liberty Bowl Memorial Stadium – Memphis, Tenn.

Launched: 1959

This Year’s Game: Iowa State vs. Memphis (Dec. 30, 2017)

It is called the Liberty Bowl because it was played in Philadelphia before moving to Memphis in 1965. As more bowls have emerged, this game has lost some of its prestige, but only one city has Charlie Vergos Rendezvous and Beale Street.

 

8. New Era Pinstripe Bowl

Location: Yankee Stadium – New York

Launched: 2010

This Year’s Game: Iowa vs. Boston College (Dec. 27, 2017)

Whoever attends this game will have to bundle up, but the upshot is that they will be in New York during the holidays.

 

7. Hyundai Sun Bowl

Location: Sun Bowl – El Paso, Texas

Launched: 1935

This Year’s Game: NC State vs. Arizona State (Dec. 29, 2017)

Launched in 1935, the Sun Bowl is the second-oldest bowl game along with the Sugar and Orange Bowls (The Rose Bowl is, of course, the oldest.). El Paso’s Sun Bowl was built in a natural bowl and to watch a game there is worth the trip.

 

6. San Diego Credit Union Holiday Bowl

Location: SDCU Stadium – San Diego

Launched: 1978

This Year’s Game: Washington State vs. Michigan State (Dec. 28, 2017)

In 1984, BYU beat Michigan 24-17 to win the national title. It is one of only two bowls on this list that has hosted a national championship-clinching game.

 

5. Belk Bowl

Location: Bank of American Stadium – Charlotte, N.C.

Launched: 2002

This Year’s Game: Wake Forest vs. Texas A&M (Dec. 29, 2017)

Charlotte is an easy city to fly to; especially for watching a good ACC school take on a good SEC school or vice versa.

 

4. TaxSlayer Bowl

Location: EverBank Field – Jacksonville, Fla.

Launched: 1946

This Year’s Game: Louisville vs. Mississippi State (Dec. 30, 2017)

You have probably have heard of this event by its original name, the Gator Bowl. Its 70-year history is one of the richest on this list so shame on TaxSlayer.com for doing away with the original name. Either way, those who go will be watching college football’s sixth-oldest bowl game.

 

3. Outback Bowl

Location: Raymond James Stadium – Tampa, Fla.

Launched: 1986

This Year’s Game: Michigan vs. South Carolina (Jan. 1, 2018)

Originally started in 1986 as the Hall of Fame Bowl, this New Year’s Day game is a rewarding trip for fans regardless of whether their team’s season lived up to expectations.

 

2. Valero Alamo Bowl

Location: Alamodome – San Antonio

Launched: 1993

This Year’s Game: Stanford vs. TCU (Dec. 28, 2017)

After paying your respects at the Alamo and enjoying the San Antonio River Walk, you can watch two teams engage in a shootout in the Alamodome. This may be the best atmosphere of the entire college football postseason.

 

1. Citrus Bowl Presented by Overton’s

Location: Camping World Stadium – Orlando, Fla.

Launched: 1947

This Year’s Game: Notre Dame vs. LSU (Jan. 1, 2018)

This game has everything. Its history includes hosting Georgia Tech’s 45-21 victory over Nebraska, allowing the Yellow Jackets to clinch a share of the 1990 national title; it is played in one of the biggest tourist destinations in the world; and the matchups are always top-notch. Since 1985, the Citrus Bowl has hosted games between ranked opponents in all but two of the matchups. Only the Gator Bowl – I mean TaxSlayer Bowl – comes close to matching that type of success.

 

— Written by Aaron Tallent, who is part of the Athlon Contributor Network. Tallent is a writer whose articles have appeared in The Sweet Science, FOX Sports’ Outkick the Coverage, Liberty Island and The Washington Post. Follow him on Twitter at @AaronTallent.

Event Date: 
Wednesday, December 7, 2016 - 09:59

More Stories: