Many recreational golfers have simple reasons for why they have a favorite golf hole. Golf course architects often use something different than looks or location to select their favorites. We asked noted designers Damian Pascuzzo, Robert Trent Jones Jr., Tom Doak, Arthur Hills and Rees Jones to share some of their favorite holes. If you can get to all of them, let us know how you did it at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Ranch Golf Club, Par 5, 510 Yards
This Damian Pascuzzo design is rated one of the best in the state, and the first hole was created with all levels of golfer in mind. “There is a comforting feel to it, looking down from the tee over a grand expanse of fairway — 75 yards wide — with a solitary hickory tree left of center, a glimpse of the lake on the left and the native grasses,” Pascuzzo says. “There’s no pressure, but, if you are confident right out of the box, you can play left of the hickory and take a risky shot at the green in two, across the lake.” Pascuzzo also put in a cluster of fairway bunkers in the second landing area to penalize golfers.
Contact: (866) 790-9333, www.theranchgolfclub.com
French Lick Resort (Ross Course), Par 4, 419 yards
French Lick, Indiana
While the Pete Dye Course at French Lick gets more attention, many like this classic Donald Ross design much better, and a recent redesign brought back many of the original 1917 features. There is an undulating fairway with two bunkers in the middle that are reachable off the tee. A third bunker on the right near the green provides the optical illusion that it is closer to the putting surface than it actually is. There is a bunker on the left, protecting that side of the green. The green has a ridge running down the middle.
Contact: (888) 936-9360, www.frenchlickgolf.com
Half Moon Bay (Ocean), Par 3, 143 yards
Half Moon Bay, California
This is not only a beautifully designed hole, but also a very challenging short par 3. Arthur Hills' objective for the hole was to utilize the ocean view and keep the natural vegetation. “It is a simple short hole framed by native grassed mounds,” Hills says. “The beauty has to be seen.” Don’t get distracted by the splendor, or a bogey is a very real possibility. The ocean breeze will be in the golfer’s face, and three bunkers on the left will catch any tee shot that goes there. A tee shot that's too long will run off the humpback green and leave a challenging chip shot.
Contact: (650) 726-1800, www.hmbgolflinks.com
Bandon Trails, Par 4, 408 yards
Although Tom Doak designed another course in Bandon (Pacific Dunes), he was impressed by the work of Bill Coore and Ben Crenshaw, especially on this challenging par 4. “The fairway features a sharp ridge running diagonally across it from left to right,” Doak says. “If you play too safely to the left and clear it, your drive will kick away to the left leaving a longer approach shot to a narrow green entrance; but if you play too boldly to the right, you won't get over the top of the ridge, and then you'll have a blind second shot at the same narrow target.”
Contact: (888) 345-6008, www.bandondunesgolf.com
Saratoga National, Par 3, 238 yards
Saratoga Springs, New York
This is the longest par 3 on the course and plays every yard of it. Most of the holes here have forced carries from the tee, and on this hole golfers must go over a small wetlands area that shouldn’t be a problem for most low- to mid-handicappers. There is a cluster of trees to the right framing the hole and creating an instant out of bounds for any slice. Going long is definitely better than short. The large bunker in the front right protects much of the putting surface. The green is oval-shaped and has subtle undulations.
Contact: (518) 583-4653, www.golfsaratoga.com
Pacific Dunes, Par 4, 316 yards
Doak designed this hole with both the scenery and the challenge in mind and succeeded on both quests. “Most people think first about the dramatic holes along the cliff tops, but this hole is the most confounding to better players,” Doak says. “It features a very narrow green set atop a ridge, with a 20-foot-deep bunker at the base of the ridge at the left front of the green, and a steep fall-off on the right side of the green, all in fairway-height grass. For most players, it's a straightforward drive followed by an accurate pitch. But good players who think they might try to drive the green run the risk of getting themselves to one side of the green, at which point it's all too easy to play back and forth across the green trying to get a shot to hold.”
Contact: (888) 345-6008, www.bandondunesgolf.com
Bay Harbor (Links), Par 5, 500 yards
Bay Harbor, Michigan
This hole has been described as one of the most picturesque in the country, and Hills, who designed the course, says that many golfers put it on their list of must plays. “Like all memorable holes it has to be seen to be appreciated,” Hills says. “The hole sticks in my memory because of the green site on a promontory, looking out over Lake Michigan. It has to be played.” From the tee box to the green, Lake Michigan runs along the right of the hole, presenting a spectacular water hazard. Anything right is gone, either in the water or in the natural vegetation of the rugged cliff. Golfers are also fighting the prevailing wind, which is in their face.
Contact: (231) 439-4028, www.bayharborgolf.com
CordeValle, Par 4, 325 yards
San Martin, California
When Robert Trent Jones Jr. designed this hole he wanted it to provide drama. Instead of making the drivable green unreceptive to tee shots, he created a green that held on for who wanted to be daring. “An exciting, drivable par 4, this straightaway downhill hole across a lake was showcased in the dramatic playoff at the 2011 Fry's.Com Open on the PGA Tour,” Trent Jones Jr. says. “From the elevated tee, if you are strong enough, you can play across the lake into a ‘catcher’s mitt’ green that will hold onto a blistering drive. If you miss, you just may be sunk.”
Contact: (408) 695-4590, www.cordevalle.com
Blackwolf Run (River), Par 4, 361 yards
Intimidation is the theme on this hole, which features water on both the left and right of the tee box. Hit a fairway wood to the left, avoiding the trees and the two fairway bunkers that designer Pete Dye has placed to grab a tee shot that looks like it is safe. Those bunkers, along with two on the two greenside bunkers, are meant to discourage long hitters from trying to reach the green from the tee. If that doesn’t, the water that guards the right side and the nearly 300 yards of carry required will make most golfers think twice and play the percentages.
Contact: (800) 344-2838, www.americanclubresort.com
Mirimichi, Par 4, 427 yards
This hole adds a little star power to our list; Justin Timberlake co-owns this eco-friendly course in West Tennessee with his parents, and it was the first course he ever played as a kid. This is a worthy hole to start the back nine and has everything a well-designed hole should have. It is picturesque, challenging and has both water and well-placed bunkers. The tee box looks out onto the fairway that doglegs to the left and protects that side with three fairway bunkers. There is another bunker on the right to capture any wayward long hitters. The green is 80 yards long and slopes severely from left to right where it is protected by a creek. The left side of the green is guarded by a bunker and native grass mounds.
Contact: (901) 259-3800, www.mirimichi.com
Lake of Isles (North), Par 3, 196 yards
North Stonington, Connecticut
Sometimes great golf holes just fall in your lap, and that is what designer Rees Jones thought when he saw the spot for this devilish short hole. “We found a small peninsula jutting out into the Lake of Isles that proved to be an idea natural greensite for the hole,” Jones says. “The green is on a left to right diagonal, requiring both proper line and distance to reach the green surface. Greenside bunkers collect shots hit long or right; the front approach allows for a bail out short of the green.”
Contact: (888) 475-3746, www.lakeofisles.com
Monarch Dunes, Par 5, 567 yards
The longest hole on the course is also the favorite of the man who designed it, Damian Pascuzzo. “The fairway is uphill, and while you can see how the landing area is framed by big trees, there is a mystery to the tee shot,” Pascuzzo says. “At the crest of the hill, there always is an anticipation of the reveal of what lies ahead on the other side. Few modern courses feature this design element. Here, you play to the middle of the hill, and then stay left, away from the bunkering with the second shot, to leave an easier approach to an elevated green.”
Contact: (805) 343-9459, www.monarchdunes.com
Waldorf Astoria, Par 4, 324 yards
Rees Jones is partial to this hole he created because of the challenges from any of the five sets of tees. “The hole presents a unique set of options off the tee,” Jones says. “The hole is a very short par 4, playing less than 300 yards from the white tees. Water protects the entire left side and rear of the hole. For the long hitter, the green is reachable from the tee, particularly since a ramp of fairway surrounds the lone frontal bunker. Playing out to the right is a safe tee shot producing a wedge into a green with distinct sections.”
Contact: (407) 597-3783, www.waldorfastoriaorlando.com
Coyote Springs, Par 4, 450 yards
Coyote Springs, Nevada
This hole utilizes one of the 11 lakes on the Jack Nicklaus signature course, but the water is more cosmetic, located mainly to the left of the four tee boxes. The real hazard is the waste bunkers on both sides of the narrow fairway. Golfers can try and cut off some of the distance with a long, well-placed tee shot down the left side that will get a little more roll as it filters down to a collection area. The green is severely undulating and has a bit of a false front. The middle of the green is in a small valley and features the easiest pin placements. Reaching a back pin can be a challenge.
Contact: (877) 742-8455, www.coyotesprings.com
Princeville (Prince), Par 5, 576 Yards
Hanalei, Kauai, Hawaii
Original designer Robert Trent Jones Jr. oversaw a recently completed $5 million renovation, and he is excited at the changes to the course, especially this hole. “This is part of a tropical dream landscape for a golf course,” Trent Jones Jr. says. “This is a classic risk/reward hole. A slight dogleg right, it presents choices along the cliffs on the right. If you risk setting your line near the edge, you can reap the reward of prime position. However, if you veer too far off line, you can be lost.” The fairway slopes from left to right and balls in the middle to right funnel to the out of bounds.
Contact: 808-826-5001, www.princeville.com/golf
Osprey Meadows at Tamarack, Par 4, 383 yards
This is the shortest par 4 on the golf course, but it is certainly no pushover. There are 10 fairway bunkers that protect the right side so long hitters will think twice trying to get to the green off the tee. There is a collection area beyond the bunkers so balls that clear have the possibility of rolling onto the putting surface. The elevation of this course provides for longer drives, but don’t be tempted to go for the green in one. The wiser play is to take an iron off the tee and aim for the generous landing area that provides a good angle in for the second shot. There is a bunker that guards the left of the green that comes into play.
Contact: (208) 325-1000, www.tamarackidaho.com
Palmetto Dunes (Arthur Hills Course), Par 4, 380 yards
Hilton Head Island, South Carolina
This is a visually intimidating hole from the tee box and due to the natural water hazard that was waiting for Hills when he began to build the hole. “It is a dogleg left and a canal running through the property set the routing,” Hills says. “One must play the course or see a plan of the hole to appreciate the challenge. The tee shot plays into a bowl. The player wants to keep the shot within the bowl. It is generous. The shot to the green plays over the canal to the green, which is small and lies along the water. The green is sloped to the water. Over the green puts the player in a hollow. Then the next shot is up and over the back of the green to a surface sloping away toward the water. The hole has angles, water and a pitched green.”
Contact: (866) 380-1778, www.palmettodunes.com
Chambers Bay, Par 5, 604 Yards
This finishing hole is quickly building up a history and tradition. Robert Trent Jones Jr. desired a course that could hold a national championship, and his work has been validated. “On this fescue highway to the home green, successfully navigating the sandy wastelands and bunkers means the work here has only just begun,” Trent Jones Jr. says. “Named 'Tahoma' in honor of a local landmark, this too, is a landmark hole, where the U.S. Open will crown a champion in 2015, and where the legendary 2010 U.S. Amateur semifinal match between David Chung and Byeong-Hun An was decided.”
Contact: (877) 295-4657, www.chambersbaygolf.com
—by John Reger