Skip to main content

Miami Marlins All-Fire Sale Team


The Miami Marlins didn’t have a good first year. Even with a new stadium, a new name, new unis, it was still the same old Marlins as it related to on-field results. This week, the Marlins traded away every highly paid contributing member of their organization not named Giancarlo Stanton.

Jose Reyes, Mark Buehrle, Emilio Bonifacio and Josh Johnson were traded this week to Toronto (assuming MLB approval) for a disgruntled mediocre shortstop, two other Blue Jays and a host of talented prospects from their minor-league system.

This isn’t the first time, however, that the Marlins' front office has completely decimated its roster. At least, this time it happened for a reason — a 69-93 record in 2012. The two previous fire sales happened directly after winning World Series in 1997 and 2003.

The collection of bizarre and sometimes insane maneuvers has created a who’s who of traded Marlins. Here is Athlon Sports' Marlins' All-Fire Sale Team. And this list below doesn’t include two huge trades that also appeared to be give-ups: Miguel Cabrera, Dontrelle Willis to Detroit in 2007 and Mike Lowell, Josh Beckett and Guillermo Mota in 2006 to Boston. Or the give-up on Hanley Ramirez this mid-season that was really the only quality chip the Marlins got in return for Beckett, Lowell and Mota.

Note: To be included on this list the player must have been traded immediately after either the 1997 or 2003 World Series Championships or included in the ridiculous salary dump that took place this week.

The Marlins' All-Fire Sale Team:

C: Pudge Rodriguez
This Hall of Famer might be one of the greatest catchers to ever play the game and he was clearly the most important and most valuable player on the 2003 championship squad. He hit .297 with 16 homers, 85 RBIs, 90 runs scored and played in 144 games behind the plate. Other options at backstop include Charles Johnson, who started on the 1997 title team and was traded in May of 1998. This is also the team that traded away Mike Piazza after only five games in a Marlins uniform.

1B: Derrek Lee
After six years, 129 homers, 417 RBIs and an .822 OPS in South Florida, the Marlins got rid off one of the most underrated first basemen of his era. A tremendous athlete who also stole 51 bases in his Marlins career, Lee had an excellent glove at first and was one of the key cogs to the 2003 World Series run.

2B: Emilio Bonifacio
This speedster has dealt with injuries, but he has played all over the outfield and infield in South Florida. He hit .271 and stole 103 bases in four seasons with the Marlins and had his best season in the majors in 2011.

3B: Jeff Conine
In his first stint with the Marlins, Conine hit .291 with 98 homers and 422 RBIs in five seasons yet was discharged following the 1997 championship. He eventually returned to South Beach and has become a strange staple of the franchise (he actually played 25 games in 2003 as well). Bobby Bonilla was also traded shortly after the 1997 title in the Charles Johnson, Gary Sheffield trade. Miguel Cabrera was also sent packing but it came four years after the 2003 World Series in which he played as a 20-year old.

SS: Jose Reyes
The $106-million man had a solid first season in Miami. He hit .287 with 40 stolen bases, 86 runs scored, 60 extra-base hits and led the league in plate appearances (716). I guess they learned enough in year one of a six-year deal to send him packing.

OF: Moises Alou
The batting glove-less Alou is a career .303 hitter in over 7,000 at-bats. He played for one year for the Marlins during their World Series run in 1997, hitting .292 with 23 homers and 115 RBIs. He played in Houston the next four seasons.

OF: Gary Sheffield
Okay, this one was shoe-horned a bit since he didn’t technically get traded until May. This guy has 509 career dingers and a career .292 batting average and he went on to play a decade more of baseball in Los Angeles, New York (both teams) and Detroit.

OF: Devon White
He certainly wasn’t the superstar centerfielder he was when Toronto won its back-to-back World Series titles, but he was still a very productive member of the Marlins for two seasons. He had a great glove in center and produced 23 bombs, 35 stolen bases and 110 runs scored in less than 800 at-bats in two seasons for the Marlins. He played four more years for three more teams after departing South Beach.

SP: Josh Johnson
Certainly, injuries have plagued the young phenom’s upside all his career. But when healthy, there have been few pitchers as dominant as Jo-Jo. He led the NL in ERA (2.30) in 2010 and boasts a career 3.15 ERA in 916.2 career innings pitched. He is 56-37 as a starter on some bad Marlins teams and should he stay healthy, could become an ace once again in the AL East.

SP: Kevin Brown
The six-time All-Star led the league in ERA in 1996 (1.89) and 2000 (2.58) and has always been considered one of the nastier pitchers of his era. He went 16-8 with a 2.69 ERA in 237.1 innings in 1997 as the ace of the Marlins' championship staff. He pitched eight more seasons in the bigs for the Padres, Dodgers and Yankees.

SP: Al Leiter
The 19-year vet helped take multiple franchises to the World Series including his championship run with the Marlins in 1997. He then landed as a Met and served as the ace for them — going 46-26 in three years following his departure from Miami. 

SP: Mark Buehrle
After 12 dependable and championship-caliber seasons in Chicago as a White Sox, Mr. Consistent signed a big contract with Miami. He won 13 games with a 3.74 ERA in over 200 innings pitched. What more do you want from a No. 2? Not enough to justify the money at 34 years of age obviously.

RP: Robb Nen
Nen was the shutdown closer the Marlins used to help win the 1997 championship. He saved 35 games, struck out 81 batters in 74.0 innings and went 9-3 overall. He went on to save at least 40 games in four of his last five seasons — all with the Giants immediately following the 1997 World Series.

- By Braden Gall

Follow @bradengall