Skip to main content

2012 NFL Fantasy Football Rankings: Defensive Backs


The 2012 NFL Fantasy Season is here. Mock drafts abound. Rookie round-ups are nearly complete. Bye week cheat sheets are everywhere. Positional rankings are popping up everywhere, which at Athlon Sports also includes Individual Defensive Players or IDPs

While the ever-important Athlon Sports 2012 Big Board, the most accurate consensus top 100 list of fantasy footballers on the web, includes the most common and used positions in fantasy football, IDPs are also a part of many leagues out there. So true to our word of providing you everything you need to get you ready for the upcoming fantasy football season, here are our IDP rankings for defensive backs (DB).

Rankings are based on Athlon Sports standard scoring for IDPs:

Solo tackle = 1 pt
Tackle assist = 0.5 pts
Sack = 3.5 pts
Interception = 3.5 pts
Forced fumble/recovery = 2 pts
Defensive TD = 8 pts
Safety = 2 pts
Pass Defended = 0.5 pts
Blocked Kick = 4 pts

Athlon Sports Fantasy Football Positional Rankings: Defensive Backs

Rank, Name, Position, Team (2011 Fantasy Points per Athlon Sports standard scoring)

1. Eric Berry, S, Kansas City Chiefs (0.0 FP)
Even if Berry, who is returning from a torn ACL suffered in Week 1 last season, is missing a half-step, he’ll be the last line on a defense that ranked top 11 in most snaps on the field in three of the past four years. If he’s near 100 percent, Berry brings corner-like ball skills to his sure, and willing, tackling ability.

2. Tyvon Branch, S, Oakland Raiders (110.3 FP)
Last year marked the first time in three seasons as a starter that Branch fell outside the top-10 DBs in a typical IDP format. He still managed to rank second at the position in total tackles.  Branch’s fantasy numbers dipped last year because of a lack of turnovers and sacks. Chalk it up to bad luck, and stay confident in him.

3. Patrick Chung, S, New England Patriots (58.5 FP)
Chung suffered one injury after another in his second season as a starter. There was thumb surgery, a foot injury that cost him nearly the entire second half, and a knee problem that hampered him into the playoffs.

4. George Wilson, S, Buffalo Bills (115.6 FP)
Last season marked the first time he opened a year in the lineup, and Wilson led all defensive backs in scoring before a Week 10 neck injury. Two years before, he boasted a top-10 scoring average over just 12 starts.

5. Eric Weddle, S, San Diego Chargers (110.5 FP)
According to Pro Football Focus, Weddle ranked third overall among safeties in 2010 and fourth last year. Weddle is as big an INT threat as any safety in the league, which he finally showed last year.

6. Kam Chancellor, S, Seattle Seahawks (115.5 FP)
Chancellor’s ability to cover ensures he stays on the field in sub packages, and that big body helped tie for 10th among DBs in solo tackles. It doesn’t hurt that his defense ranked second in scrimmage plays over the past three years.

7. LaRon Landry, S, New York Jets (51.3 FP)
Landry is as big of a gamble as anyone at the position. He scored like a linebacker in 2010, though, and was productive despite limitations last year.

8. Charles Tillman, CB, Chicago Bears (138.5 FP)
The Bears’ vet has finished outside the top eight DBs just once in the past four years. He has ranked among the top 16 six of the past nine years. Only once has he finished lower than 27th.

9. Antoine Bethea, S, Indianapolis Colts (119.0 FP)
Bethea delivered 33 more total tackles last year than in any other season. The Colts’ free safety picked off 11 passes over the previous four years and knocked away the second most of his career last season.

10. Morgan Burnett, S, Green Bay Packers (119.5 FP)
Despite a top-five fantasy season, Burnett was actually limited by a broken hand last year. After three interceptions through the first three games, he didn’t pick another until the playoffs.  He still never went more than three games without breaking up a pass and tied for third among defensive backs in total tackles.

11. Mark Barron, S, Tampa Bay Buccaneers (Rookie, DNP in NFL in ’11)
Barron profiles similarly to Eric Berry coming into the league, if not quite as talented. He has the tackling willingness to play near the line on run downs and the ball skills to stay on the field and deliver big plays. Sean Jones finished top-20 in DB tackles at the back of this defense last year, and Barron has the potential to be even better.

12. Earl Thomas, S, Seattle Seahawks (99.5 FP)
Thomas isn’t likely to post the tackle numbers of Kam Chancellor, his bigger teammate at safety, but he actually rated higher in run defense than Chancellor last season, according to Pro Football Focus. Of course, we already knew about the ball skills that helped him pick off five passes as a rookie.

13. Roman Harper, S, New Orleans Saints (119.8 FP)
Tying for 33rd in the league in sacks is no big deal — unless, of course, you’re a safety. Harper’s 7.5 sacks more than doubled the next DB’s total (Chris Crocker, 3.5). Harper’s 73 solo stops last season marked his lowest total in five years as a starter.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

14. Charles Woodson, CB/S, Green Bay Packers (121.2 FP)
Woodson has proved his ability to play multiple spots well, whether it be outside, covering the slot or at safety. Fantasy owners need not worry where he’ll play or whether he’ll produce. Woodson has finished four straight seasons among the position’s top seven.

15. Patrick Peterson, CB, Arizona Cardinals (127.4 FP)
If your league awards individual points for kick-return TDs, Peterson isn’t lasting this long in your draft. He electrified on special teams last year, but he has room to grow on defense. Pro Football Focus rated him 89th among all NFL corners in coverage, which could actually help his fantasy outlook.

16. Jairus Byrd, S, Buffalo Bills (120.5 FP)
As a rookie, Byrd posted unrepeatable interception numbers. They disappeared in a second season that saw a tackle spike. In 2011, Byrd put it all together and turned in a top-five performance.

17. Troy Polamalu, S, Pittsburgh Steelers (105.0 FP)
Polamalu has missed 21 games over the past six years. He tied for 18th at the position in total tackles last year, the first time since 2005 he ranked among the top 40. The upside, though: From 2008-10, he averaged one pass defensed per game and more than one INT for every two.

18. Quintin Mikell, S, St. Louis Rams (108.0 FP)
Mikell endured a down 2011, but it wasn’t really reflected in his fantasy stats. Mikell’s pass coverage suffered, including a dip of 10 passes defensed from the previous year, but he managed to finish 15th at the position on tackles and forced fumbles.

19. Bernard Pollard, S, Baltimore Ravens (90.0 FP)
Starting 13 games, Pollard nearly doubled his previous season high for passes defensed and forced more than one fumble for the third time in four years. Ed Reed’s continued presence should allow Pollard to play in his comfort zone, closer to the line.

20. T.J. Ward, S, Cleveland Browns (40.5 FP)
Ward says he’s over the foot sprain that cost him half of last season, but it’s hard to forget injury concerns that followed him into the league. The risk is worth it for a guy was second among DBs in 2010 in solo tackles.

21. Jason McCourty, CB, Tennessee Titans (124.0 FP)
Chalk up McCourty’s breakthrough fantasy season to two factors: He rated tops in the league in run defense among corners, according to Pro Football Focus. He also faced the third-most passes.

22. Antrel Rolle, S, New York Giants (100.1 FP)
A word of caution before you draft Rolle: The Giants spent the third-most plays in the league on defense last year, nearly 100 more than the year before. That means more tackle chances for everyone, and Rolle — not surprisingly — went for career highs in solos and assists.

23. Darian Stewart, S, St. Louis Rams (107.0 FP)
Stewart could have been looking at Roman Harper-type usage under Gregg Williams, before the bounty suspension. Even without Williams last year, though, Stewart was among the most frequent secondary blitzers in the league.

24. Dawan Landry, S, Jacksonville Jaguars (98.8 FP)
The Jags ranked 25th in defensive scrimmage plays last year. That didn’t help Landry’s numbers, though he still tied for 11th at the position in total stops. Landry enjoyed two four-INT seasons among his first three healthy campaigns with the Ravens.

25. Kenny Phillips, S, New York Giants (92.0 FP)
The most important stat for Phillips the past two years was probably games played. His 2009 knee injury led to rumors of a chronic condition that threatened to doom his career, but he has missed just one game since.

26. Antoine Winfield, CB, Minnesota Vikings (46.5 FP)
Three of the past five seasons have seen Winfield miss six games or more. His production remains stellar when he’s on the field, though, and coverage metrics suggest Winfield might even be improving in that area as he ages.

27. Charles Godfrey, S, Carolina Panthers (91.0 FP)
As you get further down the DB list, you should be seeking upside. Godfrey provides that, with five double-digit fantasy outings each of the past two seasons. Godfrey ranked third and seventh the past two years among safeties in yards allowed after the catch, according to Pro Football Focus.

28. Lardarius Webb, CB, Baltimore Ravens (116.5 FP)
Webb was one of 10 cornerbacks not to allow a touchdown in coverage last year. According to Pro Football Focus, he played significantly more snaps than all but one of those other nine guys. Webb’s tackles slipped as last season wore on, and passes defensed carried his value.

29. Reggie Nelson, S, Cincinnati Bengals (111.0 FP)
The free safety didn’t go more than two games without a pass defensed at any point last year and finally topped his rookie season production. Nelson will never be the surest tackler on the field, but the Bengals showed with his new contract that they like him at the back of their defense.

30. Brandon Flowers, CB, Kansas City Chiefs (85.0 FP)
Flowers tied for 22nd among corners in targets faced despite his team seeing the fewest pass plays in the league last year.  Over the past three years, only Darrelle Revis has broken up more passes than Flowers’ 57. That doesn’t even include the 11 INTs.

— Published on June 20, 2012

Athlon Sports 2012 NFL Fantasy Content:

Athlon Sports Big Board: Top 150

2012 Fantasy Football Mock Draft I

2012 Bye Week Cheat Sheet

Athlon Sports Fantasy Positional Rankings: QBs

Athlon Sports Fantasy Positional Rankings: RBs
Athlon Sports Fantasy Positional Rankings: WRs
Athlon Sports Fantasy Positional Rankings: TEs
Athlon Sports Fantasy Positional Rankings: DLs
Athlon Sports Fantasy Positional Rankings: LBs
Athlon Sports Fantasy Positional Rankings: IDP Top 75

Related: Order your Athlon Sports 2012 NFL Preview Magazine Here

You can preorder your award-winning Athlon Sports NFL Fantasy Football preview magazine here.