Skip to main content

2017 NFL Draft: Best and Worst Pick for Every Team

Image placeholder title

The 2017 NFL Draft is officially wrapped up and now attention for every franchise can turn fully to the upcoming season. As is typically the case after the draft, every team thinks they nailed every pick and discovered that missing starter that can lead them to the Super Bowl.

Related: Grading the First Round of the 2017 NFL Draft

While it’s too soon to say exactly how every draft pick will pan out, we can look at the value teams got from certain picks and which ones caused a few head scratches around the league. With that in mind, here are the best picks from each team and in the interest of fairness, their worst.

Arizona Cardinals

Best pick: Budda Baker, S, Round 2 (36th overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Cardinals

Worst pick: Chad Williams, WR, Round 3 (98th overall)

The Cardinals had a pretty solid draft overall, addressing needs on defense and along the offensive line. Baker has a chance to be a real steal in the second round and should contribute immediately in nickel packages. Plus he’ll get to be tutored by Tyrann Mathieu. Arizona has had luck with wide receivers in the third round but the selection of Williams there was a big reach. The Grambling State product has significant off-the-field concerns coming out of college and could have been taken much later in the draft.

Atlanta Falcons

Best pick: Sean Harlow, OG, Round 4 (136th overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Falcons

Worst pick: Duke Riley, LB, Round 3 (75th overall)

The NFC champions had a quality draft from top to bottom and it’s hard to quibble with their picks all that much. Harlow has a chance to start very early for the Falcons and really help improve the interior offensive line. Given the limitations dressing out rosters on game day, his flexibility also is a nice plus and is great value in the fourth round. As for Riley, he’s undersized and may struggle with the jump to the next level. He has a chance to be a big-time special teams contributor but spending a third-round pick on him seems a little questionable when the team could have continued to add to the secondary.

Baltimore Ravens

Best pick: Tim Williams, LB, Round 3 (78th overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Ravens

Worst pick: Marlon Humphrey, CB, Round 1 (16th overall)

Ozzie Newsome loves him some Alabama players so that’s naturally where we’ll focus in this draft. At the top, Humphrey makes a lot of sense as it comes at a huge area of need for the team and the corner really has all the physical tools to develop into a top-flight option at the position. But it’s hard not to note that they could have opted instead for Jonathan Allen or O.J. Howard with this pick and also improved the team a ton. The Ravens did get fantastic value in landing Williams in the third round though, and his off-the-field concerns should be alleviated by the team culture he lands in with Baltimore.

Buffalo Bills

Best pick: Zay Jones, WR, Round 2 (37th overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Bills

Worst pick: Tre’Davious White, CB, Round 1 (27th overall)

The Bills just let go of their general manager and most of the scouting staff but they leave Buffalo with their best draft effort in a few years. Jones in particular has a chance to really complement Sammy Watkins well and he should be Tyrod Taylor’s (or whoever’s at QB) best friend by midseason. While the team moved back quite a bit and picked up picks left and right, the Bills’ first-round selection was a bit puzzling considering how much they invested in they have already invested in the cornerback position and the fact that White is solid but not spectacular. They could have used one of those draft slots to grab a tight end in the deepest class in years instead.

Carolina Panthers

Best pick: Daeshon Hall, DL, Round 3 (77th overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Panthers

Worst pick: Harrison Butker, K, Round 7 (233 overall)

The Panthers really made it a priority to help Cam Newton in this draft and certainly did that by adding versatile offensive weapons like Christian McCaffrey and Curtis Samuel. They really landed a steal in Hall though, who has the talent to become a regular starter and regularly get into the backfield. While they did overdraft Samuel a tad in the second round, it’s strange to seem them use a seventh-rounder on a kicker. Graham Gano wasn’t great last season but you can get a solid kicker after the draft if you want competition.

Chicago Bears

Best pick: Eddie Jackson, DB, Round 4 (112th overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Bears

Worst pick: Tarik Cohen, RB, Round 4 (119th overall)

This draft will always be evaluated in terms of the Mitchell Trubisky trade and while the Bears did give up too much to move up one spot to get him, that wasn’t their worst move. That came in the fourth round, which netted them a steal in the form of Jackson but also resulted in following that up with a puzzling move a few picks later. The Alabama safety has plenty of positional flexibility and should help boost the return game right away, making him quite the steal and a nice boost to the young secondary core. As for Cohen though, this was a massive reach on a small running back, who will be no better than third on the depth chart and could have been had much, much later in the draft.

Cincinnati Bengals

Best pick: Jordan Willis, LB, Round 3 (73rd overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Bengals

Worst pick: Josh Malone, WR, Round 4 (128th overall)

It’s hard to nit-pick with the Bengals draft because they did extremely well across their whopping 11 picks in 2017. Landing Willis was a straight-up steal as he has a chance to be a rotation player at a number of spots from Week 1 and is the kind of well-coached, physical player who can jump right in on defense. While they didn’t really make any missteps on the final day, it seems like it was a little early to grab Malone in the fourth. Not only could they have gotten a more productive wideout later, they also could have waited to draft him.

Cleveland Browns

Best pick: Myles Garrett, DL, Round 1 (1st overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Cleveland Browns

Worst pick: Caleb Brantley, DL, Round 6 (185th overall)

The Browns were in many ways in control of this year’s draft and they emerged with several potential starters across the board. This is Cleveland however so while it had to be tempting to buy into the talk of Mitchell Trubisky going No. 1 overall, the team wisely waited to grab QB DeShone Kizer in the second round and instead grabbed the most talented player in the draft with the first selection. The decision to pick Brantley later on was foolish though, as it was a waste of an early sixth-round pick on a guy many thought would go undrafted due to off-the-field issues. The team apparently recognized that and might even cut him before camp as a result.

Dallas Cowboys

Best pick: Chidobe Awuzie, DB, Round 2 (60th overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Cowboys

Worst pick: Noah Brown, WR, Round 7 (239th overall)

It’s no secret that the Cowboys needed to re-tool their defense and the secondary in particular. Thus, it wasn’t too surprising to see that the focus of the draft and they landed a good one in Awuzie. He’s got length and can be flexible enough in sub-packages to line up just about anywhere when called upon. That’s great value considering where Dallas was picking and what the needs were. The selection of Brown is a little more puzzling as he seems to be a poor man’s Brice Butler, who’s already on the roster. The team is already pretty deep at wideout so Brown will need to make the squad on special teams.

Denver Broncos

Best pick: Jake Butt, TE, Round 5 (145th overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Broncos

Worst pick: Chad Kelly, QB, Round 7 (253rd overall)

The Broncos did well in this year’s draft by landing a number of frontline contributors but they really got great value in pouncing on Butt in the fifth round. People are concerned about his rehab from the ACL tear in the bowl game but that’s proven to be an injury many players can easily come back from and it’s possible he can too by the time the season rolls around. His upside means he could have gone in the second round or higher if healthy so that’s quality work by John Elway on day three. The pick of Kelly as Mr. Irrelevant was interesting though, as he very easily could have arrived in Denver as an UDFA instead given his off-the-field issues and injury history. It would have been a pick that could have been better used on a flier at linebacker.

Detroit Lions

Best pick: Brad Kaaya, QB, Round 6 (215th overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Detroit Lions

Worst pick: Jarrad Davis, LB, Round 1 (21st overall)

The Lions addressed almost all of their defensive needs and re-stocked the depth chart pretty well with this draft. The one bone to pick might be with their first pick considering Davis’ injury history at Florida and the fact that Reuben Foster, who was higher on just about everyone’s draft board, was available. Davis should start right away regardless but it was interesting to see the Detroit pass on Foster early. And while it’s not like the Lions need a QB with Matthew Stafford under center but nabbing Kaaya in the sixth is terrific value for somebody with the skill set of a potential starter. At the very least, he could be the backup as a rookie.

Green Bay Packers

Best pick: Montravius Adams, DL, Round 3 (93rd overall)

Image placeholder title

Worst pick: DeAngelo Yancey, WR, Round 5 (175th overall)

Once again, GM Ted Thompson turns in a heck of a draft lineup and landed a number of likely starters in Green Bay. It’s hard to argue with many of the selections but grabbing Yancey in the fifth was a bit bewildering considering how deep the team is at wideout and how he may have been more of a UDFA type. He doesn’t add a noticeable value on special teams either and it wouldn’t be surprising if seventh-rounder Malachi Dupre sticks around longer. Selecting Adams in the top 100 should result on a nice return as he could be better in Green Bay than he was at Auburn.

Houston Texans

Best pick: Carlos Watkins, DL, Round 4 (142nd overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Texans

Worst pick: Julién Davenport, OL, Round 4 (130th overall)

While everybody will be focusing on landing the quarterback of the future in Deshaun Watson, his Clemson teammate might end up providing even better value late in the fourth round. Watkins should step right into the rotation as a rookie and help out a defensive line that needs some players who can consistently be a presence. Fellow fourth-rounder Davenport is an intriguing pick for a team that does need some OL help but he’s a developmental guy and it is likely some time before he can take over as a starter. For a team built to win now, the Texans could have gotten additional help in the secondary instead.

Indianapolis Colts

Best pick: Marlon Mack, RB, Round 4 (143rd overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Colts

Worst pick: Zach Banner, OL, Round 4 (137th overall)

New GM Chris Ballard had a really nice debut draft with the Colts as he targeted upgrades at areas of need for the team in 2017. That’s one reason why the selection of Mack is such a nice value in the middle rounds as he gives a lot of flexibility to the offense in terms of what he can do. It wouldn’t be all that surprising to see him get some carries and learn from Frank Gore this season before eventually taking over as the starter down the road. Grabbing Banner for the offensive line was interesting as he should help on the run-blocking front but doesn’t seem like a good fit at all trying to protect Andrew Luck in the passing game.

Jacksonville Jaguars

Best pick: Cam Robinson, OL, Round 2 (34th overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Jaguars

Worst pick: Dede Westbrook, WR, Round 4 (110th overall)

The Jaguars certainly re-committed to the run in this year’s draft with the selection of Leonard Fournette with the fourth overall pick but they really doubled down on taking the pressure off Blake Bortles by grabbing Robinson. The Alabama tackle can probably play both tackle spots or slide inside and should wind up a starter early on. At the same time, they took a flier on Westbrook, who had the talent to go higher in the draft but off-the-field concerns pushed him down the board. At best he seems like the fourth wideout so Jacksonville could have gotten a tight end instead with this pick.

Kansas City Chiefs

Best pick: Kareem Hunt, RB, Round 3 (86th overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Chiefs

Worst pick: Leon McQuay III, DB, Round 6 (218th overall)

Are the Chiefs trying to win right now? Based on how this draft went, the answer appears to be more that the franchise is building for the future. Hunt was a great selection in the third round however and he could quickly become the starter in the backfield. It was a bit puzzling for them to pick McQuay in the sixth though, as he enters a bit be at a bit of a log jam in the secondary in KC and doesn’t seem like the physical type the team needs in that division. If he sticks on the roster, it will need to be on special teams.

Los Angeles Chargers

Best pick: Desmond King, DB, Round 5 (151st overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Chargers

Worst pick: Rayshawn Jenkins, DB, Round 4 (113th overall)

The freshly minted Los Angeles Chargers had a great draft as the focus was on helping Philip Rivers and it’s hard to quibble much with any of their picks beyond not getting a developmental quarterback to groom as a backup and potential replacement. Grabbing two defensive backs in the middle rounds was an interesting strategy as King looks like a potential steal in the fifth due to his ability to play corner and safety. Jenkins can turn into a quality player but isn’t much of an upgrade over either current option on the roster. It says plenty that you have to go that deep to pick apart this class for the Chargers.

Los Angeles Rams

Best pick: Josh Reynolds, WR, Round 4 (117th overall)

Image placeholder title

Worst pick: Samson Ebukam, LB, Round 4 (125th overall)

Getting Jared Goff some weapons was a clear priority and the Rams did that early and often with their picks. Reynolds has a chance to start quickly on the outside and become a dependable presence while teaming up with fellow rookie Cooper Kupp. Ebukam was an interesting selection given what the team already has on the roster at linebacker and a pick that could have been used to bolster that iffy offensive line instead.

Miami Dolphins

Best pick: Raekwon McMillan, LB, Round 2 (54th overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Dolphins

Worst pick: Isaiah Ford, WR, Round 7 (237th overall)

Miami was yet another team that really did well in addressing its needs through the draft but also got terrific value in landing McMillan at the back half of the second round. He joins a stacked linebacker group and could add a bunch on special teams while he develops into a starter. Ford has plenty of talent but seems like a bit of a long shot to stick around given the depth the team already has there and the fact that he doesn’t add much in terms of special teams value.

Minnesota Vikings

Best pick: Pat Elflein, OL, Round 3 (70th overall)

Image placeholder title

Worst pick: Rodney Adams, WR, Round 5 (170th overall)

Even though they didn’t have a first-round pick, the Vikings still left the draft in Philadelphia with a number of key players that should make an impact early on. Elflein in particular has a chance to start right away and help boost an offensive line that really struggled a season ago. HIs versatility in playing center and both guard spots really helps a team that is limited on game day to the number of people you can dress too. Adams also might be able to enter the rotation as a slot guy but drops were a big concern with him and that’s not something that Minnesota needs more of.

New England Patriots

Best pick: Conor McDermott, OL, Round 6 (211th overall)

New England Patriots schedule 2019

Worst pick: Deatrich Wise, DL, Round 4 (131st overall)

The defending champions’ draft must take into account the wealth of veterans they acquired this offseason, leaving just four picks in 2017 when all was said and done. McDermott can develop into a starter under OL coach Dante Scarnecchia and might be a nice complement to the other tackle taken in the draft. Wise seems like a bit of a reach at that spot when the team could have filled other needs.

New Orleans Saints

Best pick: Alvin Kamara, RB, Round 3 (67th overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Saints

Worst pick: Al-Quadin Muhammad, DE, Round 6 (196th overall)

New Orleans plugged some holes on defense through the draft but the addition of Kamara should really help out Drew Brees and complement Mark Ingram and Adrian Peterson quite well. He’s good value in the third and could fill that Reggie Bush role of yesteryear. Muhammad has some upside if he can clear everything up off the field but the pick would have been better used on finding a good Brandin Cooks replacement instead.

New York Giants

Best pick: Dalvin Tomlinson, DL, Round 2 (55th overall)

NFL Power Rankings: Giants

Worst pick: Davis Webb, QB, Round 3 (87th overall)

You can like a lot of what New York did in the draft this year and that starts with the first two picks. Grabbing tight end Evan Engram at No. 23 might have been a little high but that evens out considering the value the team gets in nabbing Tomlinson in the second round. He can really make things tough on opposing lines and should fit right into that locker room. Spending a third-round pick on a project at quarterback seems a little iffy given how little playing time Eli Manning has missed and how many good years he still has ahead of him.