The winless Miami Dolphins took their worst loss of the season when quarterback Chad Henne was sent to the injured reserve with a separated left (non-throwing) shoulder. The fourth-year quarterback suffered the season-ending injury on a half-hearted scramble following a botched handoff to Lex Hilliard during a busted play in the first quarter of a 26–16 loss at San Diego.
“It’s really disappointing,” said embattled Dolphins coach Tony Sparano. “The kid’s got a lot invested in this thing with this team.”
The 6’3”, 230-pound 26-year-old was a second round pick (No. 57 overall) out of Michigan in 2008. But after posting a 13–18 career record as a starter — including an 0–4 start this season — and throwing 31 TDs and 37 INTs for a 75.7 passer rating, the South Florida sun has likely set on Henne’s career in Miami.
Where is Earl Morrall when you need him?
These are not Don Shula’s Dolphins. While Henne was clearly no Bob Griese, the backup plan is nowhere near the quality of Morrall — who famously went 11–0 as a starter subbing for Griese on the 1972 Dolphins squad that finished with a perfect 17–0 record.
Following a Week 5 bye, Matt Moore will become the 16th different quarterback to start for the Dolphins since Dan Marino retired following the 1999 season. Veteran Sage Rosenfels and practice squad rookie Pat Devlin are also options. But Moore is the new man in Miami.
“It’s Matt’s job. We’ve got to get Matt ready to go,” said Sparano. “He’s a confident guy; a little different swagger to him when he gets in the huddle.”
Moore will be 16th different quarterback to start for Dolphins since Marino retired following the 1999 season. The 6’3”, 203-pound Moore arrived in Miami this season with a 7–6 record in 13 career starts for Carolina. The fifth-year pro brings a Henne-like 16 TDs and 18 INTs along with a 73.5 passer rating in his career.
Moore’s not the worst option in the world; but with a little offseason planning, the Dolphins could have had a much better situation at quarterback:
Matt Hasselbeck, Titans (via free agency, Seahawks)
The recently-turned 36-year-old was recruited to Tennessee by first-year coach and Hall of Fame offensive lineman Mike Munchak based primarily on the selling point of the team’s O-line — especially left tackle Michael Roos. The Fins are one of the few teams in the NFL with a better blindside blocker than Roos, as former No. 1 overall pick and three-time Pro Bowler Jake Long is arguably the best in the league.
Hasselbeck has completed 66.7 percent of his passes for 1,152 yards, eight TDs and three INTs for a 104.7 passer rating and a 3–1 record for the Titans — proving he can still get the job done (if he has his blindside protected).
Vince Young, Eagles (via free agency, Titans)
This was a perfect match. V.Y. may not be able to throw a five-yard crossing route, but he sure can unload a 50-yard bomb — perfect for Brandon Marshall, who is a rich man’s Kenny Britt. Young also brings a winning track record (30–17 as a starter) and an exciting boom-or-bust style that fits the city of Miami. A one-year rental of Young offered high reward in exchange for little risk.
Ryan Mallett, Patriots (via NFL Draft, Arkansas)
Miami traded its third- (No. 79) and seventh-round (No. 217) picks to Washington for the No. 62 overall selection, which was used on Kansas State running back Daniel Thomas. Quarterback, however, was a more pressing need than running back for the Dolphins. And the 6’6”, 238-pounder with the million-dollar arm and ten-cent head was worth the risk in the third round — or at least Bill Belichick thought so at No. 74 overall. The Fins did their research but did not pull the trigger on the Hog with the cannon right arm.
“I have spent a lot of time with him,” said Dolphins general manager Jeff Ireland. “He’s a nice young man, very talented kid, got a bright future.”
David Garrard, Free Agent (via Jaguars)
The Jaguars cut Garrard just days before kickoff of the 2011 season. Following Henne’s injury, Garrard (39–37 record as starter) worked out for the Dolphins, along with fellow free agents Trent Edwards (14–19) and Brodie Croyle (0–10). Reportedly, Miami was willing to sign Garrard for veteran minimum (roughly $800,000; with $425,000 counting against the cap). The 33-year-old Garrard, however, wanted no less than $1 million and negotiations broke down.
With several other teams in need of an upgrade at quarterback — namely the Colts — there will still likely be a Garrard sighting in the NFL this season.
Andrew Luck, 2012 NFL Draft (via Stanford)
Maybe this was the plan all along. “Suck for Luck” to get the No. 1 overall pick in the 2012 NFL Draft, then draft the most pro-ready passer since Peyton Manning. After all, Hasselbeck, Young, Mallett and Garrard — even Henne, for that matter — were stopgap, band-aid solutions, at best. Luck is a franchise quarterback worthy of being the heir to Marino, albeit a decade late.
On second thought, Henne’s injury might turn out to be the best thing to happen to the Dolphins since Marino fell all the way down the board to the No. 27 overall pick in the 1983 NFL Draft.