Athlon Sports will preview the upcoming 2012 NFL season with in-depth roundtable debates with our editors and other experts from around the world of football.
Q: Does being on HBO's "Hard Knocks" help the Miami Dolphins in anyway this fall?
Brian Miller, PhinPhanatic.com (@Txmedic5)
HBO's "Hard Knocks" has not done Miami Dolphins' players any favors. From Chad Johnson being cut to showcasing the lack of production in Miami's wide receivers and tight ends, the HK episodes thus far have only further added tension to a team trying to rebuild its identity. On the outside, where the fans are the ones peering in, the decision to be on "Hard Knocks" has given Miami fans something to be excited about.
The competition at quarterback alone has provided fans an opportunity to believe the future of the team is in good hands with Ryan Tannehill, while the exposure of new coach Joe Philbin is giving fans an opportunity to judge for themselves what normally is tasked by the opinion of a local media journalist. There is no right or wrong decision on joining "Hard Knocks," but it's clear that the show isn't giving anything away concretely to opposing teams. Aside from the embarrassing moments being played out for the players, I think the fans having something to hold onto may be the long term solution to turning around the image of the Miami Dolphins franchise.
Patrick Snow (@AthlonSnowman)
I do not think it does. The Dolphins need a ton of work under rookie coach Joe Philbin as they try to avoid a sixth losing campaign out of their last seven. The HBO thing is cool, but it is also a distraction for a 6-10 club who traded its top receiver (by far), cut its top tackler (Yeremiah Bell) and will start a rookie quarterback in Ryan Tannehill. NFL teams barely need publicity; people have heard of you in this league. It’s pretty simple: if the Dolphins win, fans in South Florida will show up in droves. I see "Hard Knocks" hurting that process more than it will help.
Mark Ross, AthlonSports.com
Although I have never seen a single second of "Hard Knocks," I am not sure I see any way in which the Dolphins can benefit on the field from being featured on the series. If anything, I would think the team, with a new head coach, new coaching staff and a rookie quarterback running the offense, would not want to deal with the distractions and related issues that come with being on the series. It may be great television, help increase the Dolphins' PR exposure, give the team some extra attention and perhaps help sell some tickets and/or team merchandise, but come Week 1, no one's going to care about what they saw on HBO, only what they see the team do on the field. After all, isn't there a reason all 32 NFL teams passed on being featured on it last season?
Braden Gall (@BradenGall)
Certainly, the casual fan who doesn't follow every injury report or read coaching bios will benefit from the inside look at an NFL franchise. These fans may develop some sort of connection with interesting storylines (Joe Philbin's tragedy) and intriguing personalities (Lauren Tannehill). And the diehard NFL fan, like myself, loves the behind the curtain peek at how an NFL training camp is conducted. But there may not be such a thing as extra publicity for a league that already exists entirely in a fishbowl. Ticket sales only increase if you win games. The negatives of this type of exposure, like an assault and battery arrest or a first-year head coach adapting to the league, don't seem to outweigh the slight bump in interest fans may or may not develop with your roster. The Dolphins need a spark and so I understand why they said yes to HBO, but the headaches it appears to be creating won't be worth it. There is a reason most teams have turned down the opporunity.
Nathan Rush, AthlonSports.com
There is a reason nearly every team in the NFL turned down HBO's offer to be the featured team on "Hard Knocks" this season. As entertaining as the show is for fans, it's almost always a disaster for the team actually involved. With a rookie coach and rookie quarterback, Miami needed to avoid all distractions, not invite cameras into the facilities. The only member of the Dolphins who benefited was Ryan Tannehill, who earned instant respect thanks to his lovely wife Lauren — the real star of the show.
Rob Doster (@AthlonDoster)
Yes. The Dolphins lack buzz and identity, and their "Hard Knocks" experience is helping to provide both. The greater benefit may arrive later when high-profile free agents start considering their options and remember what they saw from Miami — specifically, Lauren Tannehill — but this is a more focused and together team than it’s been in the recent past. Will it translate into wins on the field? That is unlikely, but the Dolphins were in desperate need of attention and HBO has given them more than their fair share.