Skip to main content

Raiders Did Not Overpay For Carson Palmer


by Nathan Rush

The Oakland Raiders did not overpay for Carson Palmer — they made the right move by trading for him.

Forget the 8-for-21, 116-yard, three-INT, one-pick-six performance in the second half of a 28–0 loss to the archrival Kansas City Chiefs in Palmer’s home debut. If Chris Johnson can get a six-game “preseason” after his contract holdout, then Palmer can get a two-quarter warm up refresher course.

After all, Palmer had just three practices with the Raiders under his belt and hadn’t played an NFL game since Jan. 2.

“It definitely is an uncomfortable situation to be in but it’s a good situation just to get your feet wet,” said Palmer, explaining his mindset entering the lopsided game trailing 21–0 in the third quarter.

“It’s been awhile since I played football. And to get the few reps that I got under my belt in live action, when the bullets were flying, will definitely benefit me when we have Denver coming in two weeks (after the Week 8 bye).”

That’s a solid reaction from a grounded veteran who has seen it all — from down days at USC under Paul Hackett, to laying the foundation for a Trojan dynasty under Pete Carroll, to carrying the Bengals from obscurity to mediocrity. Palmer has the easy-going California cool and the physical tools the Raiders need right now.

“Just win, baby.” That was the late, great Al Davis’ mantra for a reason; that is what the NFL, and especially the Oakland Raiders are all about.

Reject the popular opinion that the Oakland organization was robbed East Oakland-style. The Raiders definitely did not give up too much for Palmer, a 31-year-old two-time Pro Bowler who was wasting away due to the Cincinnati Bengals’ refusal to trade the quarterback who made their franchise relevant earlier this decade.

Remember, Cincinnati went to the playoffs twice (2005, ’09) in Palmer’s six seasons as the starter. Prior to drafting the 6'5", 236-pound Heisman Trophy winner from USC with the No. 1 overall pick in 2003, the Bungles had not made the postseason since 1990.

But who’s keeping score? Obviously not Mike Brown; but certainly the Raiders’ front office.

When Oakland traded for Palmer, the team had a 4–2 record in a wide-open AFC West division that includes the bi-polar San Diego Chargers, imploding Kansas City Chiefs and the John Elway-Tim Tebow soap opera that is the Denver Broncos.

Coming off of an 8–8 season — the Raiders’ first non-losing campaign since 2002 — hopes were high for Hue Jackson’s team. Then, quarterback Jason Campbell went down with a broken collarbone and the Silver-and-Bleak reality of starting backup Kyle Boller or rookie supplemental draft pick Terrelle Pryor set in. Action was necessary.

“It’s a good young team. It’s still hungry,” said Palmer, assessing his new club’s potential. “We have really good coaching and we have really good players.”

The Raiders needed a signal-caller and didn’t want to wait until the 2012 NFL Draft — which is expected to include Stanford’s Andrew Luck, USC’s Matt Barkley and Oklahoma’s Landry Jones, just to name a few — to acquire one.

Plus, Oakland hasn’t had an eye for quarterbacks lately. Since winning Super Bowl XVIII following the 1983 season, the Raiders have drafted JaMarcus Russell (No. 1 overall), Andrew Walter, Marques Tuiasosopo, Billy Joe Hobert, Todd Marinovich, Major Harris, Jeff Francis, Steve Beuerlein, Rusty Hilger and Randy Essington.

Oakland’s hand was forced when Campbell was lost for the year. Instead of sitting in the Black Hole taking losses, the Raiders went all-in by trading their 2012 first-rounder and a conditional 2013 pick for Palmer.

It was bold. It was right. Davis would be proud.

“One thing I know about Coach (Davis), he loved tall, athletic quarterbacks from USC. That’s for sure,” said Jackson. “One thing he loves, guys that can throw the ball down the field. And this man can. I think he’d have been very excited, very happy.”